- Joined
- Mar 13, 2007
- Messages
- 51,934
- Reaction score
- 25,645
Were the molester and gang member paraplegics and therefore unable to climb or dig? Because in that case you may have a point.
Otherwise, yeah, a wall wouldn't do shit. And, yeah, unrepresentative anecdotes are still unrepresentative anecdotes. When an undocumented immigrant is detained in a Guns N Roses shirt, it won't mean that immigrants are more likely to be Guns N Roses fans: it will just mean that, in a world in which 1-in-1000 people have that particularly shitty music taste and 1000 people are detained each day, you're occasionally going to find a Guns N Roses tee shirt.
Also, there are what....50,000 molesters in the US? I'm guessing that's about the right number. I doubt you would care to point to any one of those 50,000 individuals to say, without statistical backing, that the United States is a disproportionately molester-y country. Because that would be stupid.
The guns and roses analogy is perfect. Never thought of it like that, but now I can see what you mean.