- Joined
- May 12, 2008
- Messages
- 346
- Reaction score
- 0
She deserves it competitively. It's true that she probably doesn't have the well rounded game of most brown belts who take longer, but hell, neither did I when I got mine. It's a promotion intended to push the student. If you win worlds your weight and absolute, well hell, you need a brown belt. Continuing to beat purple belts is just silly.
I remember being in side control/mount with her and being fine, but she has one of the sickest guards I've ever been in--very dangerous. It's obvious where she's been spending her time but when she becomes more well rounded with time it will only get worse for the other girls.
I don't know, I think continuing to beat purple belts is EXACTLY what she should be doing. Like most of Lloyd's stars, she has clearly developed one aspect of her game above all others and you can see it as she executes the same sequence of moves over and over with great success. That's a good approach, to a point, and certainly can reap benefits in competition. But jiu-jitsu merit should not be measured simply in terms of competition success. As you state, other aspects of her game are most likely not at the same level as her "Gameplan" (to use Lloyd-Speak), and I think purple belt is exactly the place to develop those skillsets. Perhaps she has them and we simply never saw them in practice. But I think there's a big difference between dominating with one sequence of moves versus controlling a match from multiple positions and finishing in a variety of ways.
Now obviously, I'm not saying that winning with one approach over and over again is a bad thing. Certainly Roger Gracie's dominance from the mount showcases the highest level of skill. But in terms of promotion, being able to execute an admittedly brown-belt level sequence of techniques over and over against what was clearly not the greatest depth of competitive skill (come on, how many of those ladies seemed to lack even a blue-belt understanding of triangle defense?) is not enough to justify a step up to brown belt, at least not to me. Of course, we've only seen this one side of her and perhaps Lloyd feels that the rest of her game, which he sees tested all the time at his school, is of a comparable level. In that case: so be it. He's her instructor and no slouch at that. But I worry that her glass might still be a bit empty, in which case this is less about promoting her and more about promoting Lloyd Irvin.