Biggest big game playoff choking QB: Peyton Manning or Drew Brees?

?

  • Total voters
    60
ExitLUPin

ExitLUPin

K
@Steel
Joined
Oct 3, 2015
Messages
30,145
Reaction score
44,663
there can only be 1

tumblr_n0e7scaYCy1qjqxmoo1_400.gif


10efbf0678affee9b8169e72b5dc4eaf.gif
 
Peyton is the better QB imo but I've watched it choke more. To be fair I don't remember watching much Saints games
 
It's close but Peyton choked early in his career. Peyton ended up going 14-13 in the playoffs (2 super bowl rings), which isn't great by his standards but came on strong his second half of his career. I even think he got the best of Brady a few times in the playoffs. I could name a bunch of guys who choked harder than these two though...Matt Ryan, Philip Rivers, Elway (Yeah, he was choker until they ran the ball), Marino etc...
 
Last edited:
The Saints losses for the most part hasn't been on Drew Brees. His playoff stats are on par with his regular season stats.
 
Peyton and it ain't close.
 
Peyton choked more but I’d take him over Brees though
 
Krixes said:
It's close but Peyton choked early in his career. Peyton ended up going 14-13 in the playoffs (2 super bowl rings), which isn't great by his standards but came on strong his second half of his career. I even think he got the best of Brady a few times in the playoffs. I could name a bunch of guys who choked harder than these two though...Matt Ryan, Philip Rivers, Elway (Yeah, he was choker until they ran the ball), Marino etc...
Click to expand...
He has a winning record against Brady in the playoffs, 3-2.
 
Gregolian said:
It's Rivers or Ryan. That 28-3 collapse in the playoffs will live on forever.

Scam not diving on the fumble is pretty bad too.
Click to expand...

the packers first sb run the failcans got embarrassed at home by the packers too as the number 1 seed lol.
 
Corona said:
the packers first sb run the failcans got embarrassed at home by the packers too as the number 1 seed lol.
Click to expand...
Not nearly as bad as the 28-3 in the Super Bowl. Weren't the Pack likea 5th or 6th seed that year too?

And it was our first SB run with Rodgers thanks. Not our first ever.



The Walken narration over the video is lol-inducing but also awesome. Cause I'm into corny shit.
 
Gregolian said:
Not nearly as bad as the 28-3 in the Super Bowl. Weren't the Pack likea 5th or 6th seed that year too?

And it was our first SB run with Rodgers thanks. Not our first ever.



The Walken narration over the video is lol-inducing but also awesome. Cause I'm into corny shit.
Click to expand...


yeah I meant Rodgers first sb run
 
the one time Rivers even remotely had a chance...LT sat out with a knee injury

there's no way Rivers is above Brees or Manning. People forget that Brees did jack and shit in SD before Rivers got there
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,236,980
Messages
55,458,949
Members
174,787
Latest member
Freddie556

Share this page

Back
Top