Better resume at UFC HW: Jones or DC?

Oh, man, 7 foot tall... Its really very impressive, I suppose only Struve maybe is on his level! Most dominant kickboxer, wow... You really open my eyes, thanks.

So err...what are Ciryl Ganes striking credentials again for you to be hyping him up? a competitive decision win over Volkov? beating Derrick Lewis? getting rocked by Tai Tuivasa? HW Muay Thai fights in France with one of the two opponents of his who actually has a wiki page being some dude who was one of the four guys that a 39 year old Semmy beat in one night on his literal last night ever competing?
 
DC for sure
jones has like 2 wins at HW
 
The loss to stipe alone still puts DC over jones at hw. Beating a deer in the headlights Gane and a decrepit old stipe isn’t very impressive for someone that’s supposed to be one of the best to ever fight.
 
So err...what are Ciryl Ganes striking credentials again for you to be hyping him up? a competitive decision win over Volkov? beating Derrick Lewis? getting rocked by Tai Tuivasa? HW Muay Thai fights in France with one of the two opponents of his who actually has a wiki page being some dude who was one of the four guys that a 39 year old Semmy beat in one night on his literal last night ever competing?

You want to really compare Semmy and Gane as mma fighters? Oh, man, Im done with you. Semmy is much much better obviously, no contest!<DCrying>
 
You want to really compare Semmy and Gane as mma fighters?

So how would you say Gane beats Semmy in an MMA fight? does he turn into D1/ADCC Gane all of a sudden and outgrapple a guy who survived the distance on the ground with prime Fedor? or does he just outstrike a 6'11 elite K1 guy?
 
So how would you say Gane beats Semmy in an MMA fight? does he turn into D1/ADCC Gane all of a sudden and outgrapple a guy who survived the distance on the ground with prime Fedor? or does he just outstrike a 6'11 elite K1 guy?

Obviously Semmy is much better MMA striker<BC1>
 
Obviously Semmy is much better MMA striker<BC1>

"MMA striker" lol. What exactly about MMA striking would suddenly make you confident that Gane could outstrike Semmy Schilt?

Seriously the insane overhyping of Gane on here by some to try and prop up Jons HW resume is one of the funniest things ive seen in recent memory. I actually like Gane too but Jesus Christ.
 
"MMA striker" lol. What exactly about MMA striking would suddenly make you confident that Gane could outstrike Semmy Schilt?

Seriously the insane overhyping of Gane on here by some to try and prop up Jons HW resume is one of the funniest things ive seen in recent memory. I actually like Gane too but Jesus Christ.

No, Semmy Shilt was a beast, creature, man amoung the boys, thats why he had 14 losses and lost to Yvel, Kondo, Funaki, ect I even cant write correctly their names... And Gane lost to Ngannou and Jones (both with wrestling, actually outstriking Ngannou)... Obviously Semmy is better and likely will outstrike prime Ngannou...Maaaan... just...
 
No, Semmy Shilt was a beast, creature, man amoung the boys, thats why he had 14 losses and lost to Yvel, Kondo, Funaki, ect I even cant write correctly their names... And Gane lost to Ngannou and Jones (both with wrestling, actually outstriking Ngannou)... Obviously Semmy is better and likely will outstrike prime Ngannou...Maaaan... just...

Styles make fights. And i'm asking you again, why would you be so confident that Gane would beat Semmy in an MMA fight? do you acknowledge that Gane has limited MMA experience and grappling having had his first MMA fight at 28? do you also acknowledge that, as pretty as his striking is, he lacks power, is much smaller and his striking credentials pale in comparison to Semmys? so yeah, i'm interested to hear what his fool proof risk free path to victory is in that fight?

Also lets bring this back to the root of why Semmys name was mentioned, you said Josh Barnett would get knocked out quickly by Gane. I pointed out that Josh fought multiple elite K1 guys, two of the best boxers in HW MMA history and just generally multiple guys who rank highly among the biggest hitters ever in MMA, so why would Gane, who has if anything below average power, knock him out quickly?

Btw put Gane against the versions of Stipe, Bigfoot, Barnett and Mir that DC beat and he likely loses more than he wins, possibly even loses all. You're overrating the shit out of him and we all know why.
 
Styles make fights. And i'm asking you again, why would you be so confident that Gane would beat Semmy in an MMA fight? do you acknowledge that Gane has limited MMA experience and grappling having had his first MMA fight at 28? do you also acknowledge that, as pretty as his striking is, he lacks power, is much smaller and his striking credentials pale in comparison to Semmys? so yeah, i'm interested to hear what his fool proof risk free path to victory is in that fight?

Also lets bring this back to the root of why Semmys name was mentioned, you said Josh Barnett would get knocked out quickly by Gane. I pointed out that Josh fought multiple elite K1 guys, two of the best boxers in HW MMA history and just generally multiple guys who rank highly among the biggest hitters ever in MMA, so why would Gane, who has if anything below average power, knock him out quickly?

Btw put Gane against the versions of Stipe, Bigfoot, Barnett and Mir that DC beat and he likely loses more than he wins, possibly even loses all. You're overrating the shit out of him and we all know why.

Styles make fights and thats why Semmy lost to 10 nonames and Gane only to best of the best? Its very interesting. Its diferrent class of fighter than your countless Barnetts and Semmys of the world. Its gatekeepers, like Tai, Lewis or Spivac today. Gane beat them alll easily. Stipe vs Gane its only one fight which Gane might lose from your ppropositions, others its no contest - easy win for Gane.
 
And what about Stipe, best HW of all-time aside Fedor?
I wonder why Stipe retired after losing. He's clearly in the prime of his life.

Anyways gents, the troll thread was fun. This recent post took it a bit too far though, killed the vibe.
 
I wonder why Stipe retired after losing. He's clearly in the prime of his life.

Anyways gents, the troll thread was fun. This recent post took it a bit too far though, killed the vibe.

Oh, sorry, only Khabib can retire at his prime...
 
Because for me its matter. Bigfoot and Barnett were two gatekeepers borderline top10 HW at the time.

Beating Stipe and 3 gatekeepers and losing to past-prime Stippe 2 times is better than beating Gane and post-prime Stipe? Interesting.
Remind me, how old was DC back then?

DC beat the younger closer to his prime Miocic, lost to him after, 40-something years old DC, Gane is a good win, but DC has a longer resume at HW and some very decent wins while at it.
 
Who's resume at UFC HW are better: Jones or DC?

DC resume:

Mir win

Nelson win

Stipe win

Lewis win

Stipe loss

Stipe loss



Jones resume:

Gane win

Stipe win



Which is better for now and why?
DC and its not even close

DC also won the Strikeforce GP, (that Fedor was knocked out of Round 1) and UFC Gold

Prior to Jones, DC never lost a single round at HW.

If it werent for that dumb decision to move to HW (For his gangbanging homie) , Im convinced he would have been the best HW ever
 
Back
Top