- Joined
- Jan 6, 2014
- Messages
- 3,320
- Reaction score
- 4
Because it was a world championship fight and Judah was on his feet seconds after Nady waved it off. That fight could have gone on. I actually had forgot that that took place so late in the round, not that it really matters, other than my comment about Zab making it out of the round.
It seemed like more of an equlibrium problem than Judah being actually badly hurt. Tszyu landed a good shot and fought a good fight, don't get me wrong. But Nady should have followed referee protocol and given Zab the chance to get to his feet, then make the decision if Judah was fit to fight.
That was not the same thing. Montiel had a seizure for fucks sake. Zab lost his legs for a moment.Have I not heard u say u were ok with the donaire v monteil continuing even after monteil was doing his tortoise on his back impersonation also?
Is steve smoger your fav ref? haha. as you rightly say what time it is in the rnd is irrelevant ( as you have pointed out when speaking of jcc vs taylor stoppage too IIRC).
That was not the same thing. Montiel had a seizure for fucks sake. Zab lost his legs for a moment.
Steve Smoger is a shit ref.
And... Richard Steele followed the ref protocol that i sited in my post.
Pwnt.
My point is you seem wildly inconsistent as to what constitutes a good stoppage. IIRC ( and I apologise in advance if I
Marvelous Marvin Haggler
Still think Nady should have finished the count.
jm has probably 100 beautiful gifs that could display that he belongs in this thread.. Just an amazing puncher...
Reminds me
ricardo lopez
beautiful puncher
I never said that though. I said the ref could be excused for not stopping the montiel fight because he didn't see the fit that Montiel had. His back was to Montiel when Montiel flopped around. I never said what you claimed I said.
I'm not sure what you don't get about what I'm saying. The ref should have simply finished the count and seen if Judah was OK to go. Thats what the ref is supposed to do.
----
http://abcboxing.com/documents/ABC_REFEREE_GUIDELINES.pdf
KNOCKDOWN MECHANICS
1. Command
This was one of the worst things I've ever witnessed in my life. What was that refs name? I don't think boxing is fixed or anything like that but if there ever was an argument this was it.