- Joined
- Nov 15, 2010
- Messages
- 4,697
- Reaction score
- 0
Honestly, they where more or less the same experience as you... and besides the instructor (which you had a decent scrap with, Ill admit) and the douche, they were more or less tai chi sparring lol and they couldnt kick for shit, remember where talking about a kicks based opponent here...
You can check my sparrings , I drop my hands too, but not with kicks involved... thats just crazy lol
And what did Sinister said about sparring at my experience again? C'mon now.
you said that in the "hands up thread", where you posted some karate shotokan guy pic to prove your point, forgetting that in shotokan rules there are NO low kicks, that's why kyokushin guys have a more squared stance. (by the way, i like that old school boxing stance and his principles as sinister explained them...i didn't know it but now i think i'd like to learn it. But i'm not using it for sumo, muay thai or soccer)
i've read the "whole story". so?
you were the one out of context, sparring against KK guys in their rules like it was a boxing match, as if your boxing stance could fit every ruleset.
And i think this is thread related, because teach us a lesson: every stance/style/posture has a "why" and it's related to his context.
The hunched front-weighted posture of Petrosyan works GOOD in his context. There is not an "absolute-correct-form" for every sport.
Again, the fact that the competition doesn't allow it in its rule set does not rule out its existence. I did said that previously (do you even remember?). In WTF Taekwondo competition the rules don't allow low kicks and there are barely (if not none) punches allowed. But i could bet that in Taekwondo they teach punches and low kicks (simply because i did trained with a taekwondo black belt while in UK and he confirmed that). The same could be said for Shotokan karate too. In fact i think Machida himself uses low kick from times to times as a trip, which confirming its existence. And no, Kyokushin karate does not have a square stance only because of low kick. It is not even that square.
Also, i did stated in the thread about my experiences adapting my stance and principals in a Kyokushin context, and it worked to an extent for my skills level. Hence why i tried to get a video up later on for discussion, but it turned out to be more than i asked for for some weird reasons, but still i went forward and post it up.
While yes, every basic stance/style/posture have a why in its context and there's no absolute correct form, that doesn't rule out that people can adapt different things, principals, stances and nuances from other arts to the context they needed if they can venture out of their sport, which is really what i am doing with my old school boxing in different contexts (kickboxing, MMA...). There's a reason why nakmuays and kickboxers learn pure boxing, and MMA fighter come and learn BJJ from Black Belt BJJers, simply because there are things that they can learn adapt when they needs to step up to their competition.
And also, even if there's no absolute correct form, there are, i believe however, the most "efficient" form simply because of physics. Hence in the OP regarding the chest up, chin down with subsequent examples in boxing/mma/kickboxing as how a simple thing such as posture can make a different in fight. Even with Petrosyan, yes his posture is not as proper as per the OP, but comparatively speaking vs his peers, his posture is great, which facciliate his defense vs the other kickboxer. I bet if he get his posture better, his ability to fight will increase tenfolds.
And lastly, let's not clog up the thread. If you want to debate more, take it to PM please.