Anderson is the goat. Fedor does not come close.

[Anderson Silva]

Anderson
DC
Jones
GSP
MM
Dan Henderson
Fedor

Anderson just fought the MW champ of the UFC and put up a really good fight at age 40!

Fedor is younger than Anderson and just got beat up by Fabio.

Anderson has been fighting top guys ever since his loss where as Fedor has been can crushing.


Anderson is the goat, he will be fighting fucking Uriah HALL who would most likley kick Fedor to oblivion... GSP retired on top and did not can crush/attempt to can crush.

Fedor handpicked Fabio and still got beaten.

----- More

1) Fedor never fought in the UFC.
2) Fedor a legit HW got knocked out by a 185er in Dan Henderson(See below)
3) He got pounded by Big Foot (Who had already lost to Werdum... who got beat by a green DC in his next match and then by Cain.)
4) These losses came IN HIS PRIME, he was 33-34 when he got beat by Werdum, murdered by Big Foot and knocked cold by Dan Henderson.

5) Anderson's first loss in years came when he was 38(THIRTY EIGHT.) 5 years later than Fedor's loss.
6) His second loss came VIA leg break.
7) He fought Nick who is legit
8) He lost to Bisping at age 41. Bisping is no can and Anderson performed really well in that fight after a long layoff.

Fedor lost earlier and to bad competition. Anderson lost to top 5 fights when he was late into his 30's early 40's. In his late 30's Fedor is fighting cans.



---Edit GIFS

Fedor in his prime when he finally decided to step up.

DC who is the same size as Fedor (actually even shorter) dominating Bigfoot

Fedor in his prime.

Fedor against top 50 heavyweight at 39. (Who he handpicked)

Anderson at 41 against the MW champion of the UFC.

Bones against DC one of the best heavyweights of all time (who Fedor never fought)

GSP fought everyone in his weight class never ducked anyone or can crushed.

Jose reigned the 145 division and fought the top fighters in that division. (Unlike Fedor)

Fedor is not above Anderson, Jones, GSP and if DC wins against Jones or loses but dominated at HW he will not be above DC.










Do tell me more about how Fedor is goat..

 

[mastodon06]

 

[gimp0]

Glad to see Anderson still gaining new fans in 2016.

 

[bdthrill]

Can we have 2 GOATs?

 

[Fraser B]

Anderson comes close but he's just not Fedor. Fedor has always been better than everyone.

 

[Arm Barbarian]

 

[KONE]

What if they were both really good

 

[muaymilk]

Anderson is the goat and always will be. Nobody has had a run like that. Nobody.

Anyone that thinks otherwise is simply uneducated on the matter and wasn't around to see it happen in real time

 

[Zarra]

 

[ChildoftheCorn]

Anderson Silva says Anderson Silva is GOAT. ChildoftheCorn says ChildoftheCorn is GOAT, so stalemate.

Really though it's a reasonable argument. I've always thought Anderson and Fedor had the best arguments with Jones and GSP close. And I've been told Conor is 5th.

 

[mommas homeboy]

Anderson just fought the MW champ of the UFC and put up a really good fight at age 40!

Fedor is younger than Anderson and just got beat up by Fabio.

Anderson has been fighting top guys ever since his loss where as Fedor has been can crushing.


Anderson is the goat, he will be fighting fucking Uriah HALL...

You’re a fuckin’ idiot, TS. Just like so many other Sherdoggers.

And your argument is garbage.

That’s all for now.

 

[Redhawks100]

Anderson comes close but he's just not Fedor. Fedor has always been better than everyone.

What the fuck? Hahaha

 

[Redhawks100]

TS, Sherdog is the home of the Fedor cult. Don't even try.

 

[HI SCOTT NEWMAN]

Anderson Silva 0-3 since 2013. Fedor 5-0 since 2013 .

 

[Fahrenheit1221]

Jones > GSP > Anderson > Fedor

Based on dominance and strength of schedule.

 

[Nihilism]

Jones and GSP easily eclipse Anderson. Quit putting Anderson and Fedor's names in the same sentence, unless your name is Ariel Helwani and you're talking about your collection of bobblehead dolls.

 

[kahymo]

what about Rickson Gracie

GOAT mean nothing in boxing or mma,
you can't compare a 125pounds fighter with a 185 or 260pounds fighter, they do things differently

Jones and Anderson would get murked by the elite boxers in a striking match

 

[Coconut Joe]

Why can't they both be great TS?

 

[Redhawks100]

Anderson Silva 0-3 since 2013. Fedor 5-0 since 2013 .

Look at who they are fighting.

 

[Redhawks100]

Jones and GSP easily eclipse Anderson. Quit putting Anderson and Fedor's names in the same sentence, unless your name is Ariel Helwani and you're talking about your collection of bobblehead dolls.

Nah. It's Jones and Silva and then everyone else. GSP is a point fighter that couldn't finish his career (as well as fights) and ran away from his biggest title challenge.