A Fight Dr.'s Take On Roy Nelson's Granite Chin

agreed itd interesting, but i think there is more than physiology to it, but some psychology as well.

im expecting flames, as i realize this is a shitty explanation of my theory on my part.

EDIT:
While I think that there is no doubt that there are certain factors that contribute to a “granite chin”, I humbly question some of the points being put forth in the article.

To be specific, I think there is obvious logic in suggesting that the strength of certain neck muscles (e.g.- the sternocleidomastoid) can help a fighter retain rigidity when being struck.

I do NOT agree that multiple shots would necessarily weaken these muscles, in fact I think the opposite carries as much credibility- the more the muscles are employed to maintain posture, the stronger they should become.

IMHO, and I admit this is based on personal experience and observation, there is a flash moment when a fighter is given the subliminal option to “g out”, which to a certain extent is, I believe, a choice.

I think its interesting to note most fighters that are thought to have a “granite chin” are also known to showcase a certain stubbornness in all areas, even be it contract negotiations.

All of the fighters that come to my mind in this category – (Hunt, A Silva, Hendo, Nelson, etc) are all known to have obstinate personalities, and I think that when given the subtle option of going out, their mind simply chooses not to, in the same way that they often choose the harder road in all areas of life.

Im not aware of any “granite chin” fighters who are also known for being weak minded, which suggests to me that there is more than just physiology at work here.

Once a fighter gives in to this subtlety, and DOES go out, their body finds a much more comfortable ending, thereby making the decision easier to make each time.

Again, just a personal theory, hopefully my edit explains my opinion better. Sorry for long read.
 
Last edited:
fascinating1ts.jpg
 
MMA fans, commentators, and writers can wax poetic all they want about Nelson's iron chin and warrior's heart

... and lion's mane
 
agreed itd interesting, but i think there is more than physiology to it, but some psychology as well.

im expecting flames, as i realize this is a shitty explanation of my theory on my part.

I agree with you as well. Some people handle getting 'rocked' better than others. Nelson seems to have no problem getting hit in the face, while someone like Brock Lesnar didn't really adapt well to that element in MMA.
 
Good to hear this kind of stuff from a professional
 
I've seen Nelson get knocked out before. His chin isn't granite. It's more like limestone.
 
I agree with you as well. Some people handle getting 'rocked' better than others. Nelson seems to have no problem getting hit in the face, while someone like Brock Lesnar didn't really adapt well to that element in MMA.

agreed.

perhaps my "edit" makes my point a bit better.
 
agreed itd interesting, but i think there is more than physiology to it, but some psychology as well.

im expecting flames, as i realize this is a shitty explanation of my theory on my part.

EDIT:
While I think that there is no doubt that there are certain factors that contribute to a
 
So what the doc indirectly saying is that AA is fine!!! BOOOOOOOOOOOOOM
 
Interesting read. Everyone start working out your neck muscles and genetics NOW!
 
they forgot to mention the cushioning effect of the beard
 
Interesting read. Everyone start working out your neck muscles and genetics NOW!

I did like 50 genetic burpees in a row this morning..... honestly I feel like my muscles are bursting out of my genes.

My girl digs it too. She goes deep on that genome, son.....
 
Speaking as an engineer, I believe Roy's belly acts as a tuned mass damper to quickly reduce the amplitude of his brain vibration.

The mass of a persons belly is a critical factor in determining its reasonant frequency - in Roy's case his big belly is perfectly tuned to cancel the brain oscillations. That's why he is unwilling to lose weight, it would destroy his chin.
 
Back
Top