Who's top 5 wins are better Stipe or Fedor's?

Who's top 5 wins are better Stipe or Fedor's?

  • Stipe

    Votes: 64 34.4%
  • Fedor

    Votes: 122 65.6%

  • Total voters
    186
Stipe
1 .Fabrico Werdum
2. JDS
3. Francis Ngannou
4. Alistair Overeem
5. Mark Hunt
HM: Andrei Arlovski

Fedor
1. Nog
2. Cro Cop
3. Andrei Arlovski
4. Tim Slyvia
5. Semmy Schilt
HM: Mark Hunt
Why put Semmy when you could have put Heath Herring? Herring was ranked higher than Schilt. Ranked #3 or #4 or #7 by many outlets.
 
Both are impressive... Beat the top guys at the time. Just wish we could have seen Fedor in the Octagon right after Pride...
 
Stipe. It's time Fedor fans jump on the Stipe bandwagon.
 
Fedors best wins

Nog 2x
Crocop
Sylvia
Arlovski
Coleman 2x
Randleman
Mir
Schilt
Herring
Arona
Roger's
Lets be real, he lost that Arona fight. You probably havent even seen the fight for you to mention Arona in his best wins.
 
Stipe's wins remind me of Weidman's championship wins... they are legitimate... but definitely not "prime wins". He has a long way to go to surpass Fedor
 
Why put Semmy when you could have put Heath Herring? Herring was ranked higher than Schilt. Ranked #3 or #4 or #7 by many outlets.

Semmy was ranked #5 when they fought.

2abe0055-312a-493f-802a-c44b6f8e57d5.png


Herring was ranked #15
0483e771-799f-441e-a21d-c65ed93f7425.png
 
Stipe only beat up old men who stayed relevant because the division is so weak.

Then the only young guy he beat doesn’t even have a ground game and relies on landing one big shot.
 
The Werdum win is mad underrated on here. Werdum is the same guy who handed Fedor his first loss, then subbed both Cain and Nog.
 
Stipe. Nog and CC's career really went down hill when they came to the UFC
 
Werdum>nog

Big Nog beat Werdum back when he was good.
Arlovski and Kharitonov also beat Werdum.
If Werdum had done better against Nog or Sergei, he could have been another guy who got knocked senseless by Fedor. But he wasn’t in that class.

Werdum beat a washed up grandpa version of Nog much later.

There should be a noob sub-forum for children like you.
Take a hike.
Grown ups are talking here.
 
Arlovski was on 6 fight winning streak
Reem was on 4 fight winning streak
Jds was still amazing

Randleman prime years was in his ufc and he was losing left and right in pride
Tim was fat And way out of shape when he fought fedor
Losing left and right in pride because the competition was tougher .
 
Semmy was ranked #5 when they fought.

2abe0055-312a-493f-802a-c44b6f8e57d5.png


Herring was ranked #15
0483e771-799f-441e-a21d-c65ed93f7425.png
Those are automated rankings by Fight Matrix. Those are not authentic rankings.

Herring was legit ranked #7 by MMAweekly (which was one of the biggest if not the biggest rankings site at the time.) He was also ranked #3 and #4 by other legit rankings at the time of the fight.

MMA WEEKLY - Feb 2002

Heavyweights

1. Randy Couture 2. Rodrigo "Minotauro" Nogueira 3. Pedro Rizzo 4. Igor Vovchachyn 5. Ricco Rodriguez 6. Mario Sperry 7. Heath Herring 8. Mark Coleman 9. Josh Barnett 10. Kazuyki Fujita.

And Herring beat Igor that same month
 
The list is wrong

1. Nogueira
2. Nogueira
3. Crocop
4. Arlovski
5. Sylvia

Fedor is greater
 
Love me some Fedor, but Stipe is not only breaking heavyweight records, the man's doing it in style with a recently broken KO streak.
 
no he is not. You guys are smoking something real good to think a non explosive fighter with SHIT stand up game, and ZERO ko or striking ability is somehow as big of threat as true evolved and prime jds, cain, werdum, or overeem.
shhh.jpg
 
Those are automated rankings by Fight Matrix. Those are not authentic rankings.

Herring was legit ranked #7 by MMAweekly (which was one of the biggest if not the biggest rankings site at the time.) He was also ranked #3 and #4 by other legit rankings at the time of the fight.

MMA WEEKLY - Feb 2002

Heavyweights

1. Randy Couture 2. Rodrigo "Minotauro" Nogueira 3. Pedro Rizzo 4. Igor Vovchachyn 5. Ricco Rodriguez 6. Mario Sperry 7. Heath Herring 8. Mark Coleman 9. Josh Barnett 10. Kazuyki Fujita.

And Herring beat Igor that same month
Not that I don't believe you, but do you have a source for that? I would like another website to go to for rankings. Fight Matrix's generated historical rankings can be a little dodgy.
 
Back
Top