Yeah, but you didn't address any of the fights I was talking about.
What about the Howard and Natal losses? He was happy to coast to a loss because he didn't have an answer to the pressure. Even the Whitakker fight - yeah, Rob went on to win the interim belt and is probably the best striker in the division, but Hall didn't know that at the time. Again, he was just evasive to the pressure and coasted to another loss. He didn't even try to rally back in any of those fights.
The Natal loss is certainly a knock on him being a headcase. He talks about being a nice guy, then we find out there's a lot of bad blood between him and Natal, and the guy still ends up fighting incredibly passive.
And what's Brunson's win streak at the time got to do with anything? Hall backed straight up when pressured, because again, that's what he does when someone brings it.
Brunson's m.o. in those wins are related to how Hall lost that fight, meaning Brunson was blitzing a lot of people in similar fashion. He is a fast, explosive guy who was going all out in the first minute of a fight, trying to get that big finish. Any fighter getting attacked that way is at heavy risk if they're not careful. Which at the same time, also makes it very dangerous for Brunson himself by either exposing himself or gassing out. I don't think any of those elements inherently have to with the concept that Hall has quit in him.
Also, that fight lasted less than 2 minutes, with at least 2 instances of Hall coming forward and them clinching. Hall was also not backing up in a straight line, he was side stepping before the big ko, but Brunson adjusted and also took a step to the side and threw the punch that ko'd Hall. Nothing about those moments scream he lost due to lack of willpower.
But even considering he does have a tendency to back up in a straight line, but that imo is more a defensive issue than a mental one. I think he got caught like that in the Weidman fight (pre UFC) and I think he also got in trouble like that vs Gastelum.
We might just have to agree to disagree, but you can't deny that for such a talented and explosive striker, the guy folds like a lawn chair in fights that he really shouldn't.
We probably don't disagree as much as you'd think. I can agree there is some truth to the common perception of him. But I basically think he's not as much a quitter as people say, and on the opposite end, I don't think he has as high a ceiling as people claim either, he's not some young buck just starting out. He certainly looks the part of a bad-ass fighter, but there is a lot more to getting to the upper echelon than being athletic and having cool ko's.