I've been posting here for close to a decade and IMO, the best threads all came from the OG Bareknuckle off topic discussion back around 2005-2009. I remember the mods comming down hard not the forum and banned a shit ton of posers which I forget why.
A few good ones the mods should consider (if you can find them or were around at the time):
-Some guy kept posting about how he was consistently tapping out blue belts and purple belts despite being a white belt himself. The OT ended up finding where the guy rolls at and contacted the instructor which then got the dude kicked out of the gym.
-The " i think you should call the cops" thread. Some guy decided to try bjj for the first time and was rolling with the instructor. The instructor jammed his thumb under the area of the dudes balls and he was asking sherdog if the move is legit lol.
-Their was a dude with shaggy hair who called out everyone in the off topic forum. He started posting pictures of himself, his girlfriend and his gun collection. Everyone was ripping him apart be the man kept comming back with gold.
-This dude went on a date with this blonde chick he never met before and decided to post the pictures of the date for all of the OT to see. The thread reaches around a 100 pages of posters just insulting the poor OP.
Edit:
Anyone remember these guys?