Always fun to rehash this one, so here's my take after probably my 5th time watching it:
Round 1: Hendricks by a smidge. Both guys got a takedown with negligible damage scored off of it. GSP went for a mediocre sub attempt, landed some good lead leg low kicks and was touching Johny with the jab. Johny landed a couple big lefts, good knee up the middle, worked his own power low kicks, kneed GSP to the thighs HARD and elbowed GSP up pretty good against the fence. Close round, but I think you gotta give it to Johny. As an asdie, does anyone else feel like Compustrike just gets it totally wrong sometimes? They had Johny way ahead in terms of sig strikes landed towards the end of the first and I just didn't see it that way.
Round 2: Big Rigg. Clearly.Rocks GSP a couple times, works him over with GnP and busts his face wide open, while GSP sticks to the jab and lead leg attacks.
Round 3: GSP, but it's closer than a lot of people recall. GSP started landing his right in this round along with the jab and lead kicks he hit all night and Big Rigg looked like he was starting to slow down, but he picked it up in the last minute and managed to take GSP down off a single and keep him there till the end. Still GSP's round.
Round 4: Hendricks has his second wind and starts landing his left again (he loved the uppercut here) and GSP carries on with his attacks. Whenever these guys clinch up, Hendricks just jacks the underhook up and shoves him against the fence. No one before or since had that kind of success against Georges. Hendricks wins.
Round 5: GSP takes this round. He stuck with his gameplan on the feet, avoided the big attacks of Johny, and gets a (brief) take down late. Give it to Georges.
Bottom Line: Damn good fight, a lot of high-level stuff in here, and it's still a decision I can't agree with. The more I watch it though, the less clear cut the 1st round is for Johny and as many have already stated, that was the round this fight's outcome ultimately hinged on. In no way, shape, or form was this a robbery or even in the Top 25 worst decisions in MMA history, although it is probably the most high-profile close decision in the sport's history.
As they say, we can both disagree on something and neither one of us has to be wrong.
Of course, they also say we can disagree on something with equal conviction and the truth doesn't have to lie in the middle...