- Joined
- Jul 21, 2007
- Messages
- 11,868
- Reaction score
- 875
Culpepper's feelings and ego got the best of him! He was holding grudges against Tai instead of thinking about whether Tai or Sarah was the biggest threat to him.
I have no doubts Brad would've won just based off the fact Tai can't articulate anything ever. His final tribal performance in Kaoh Rong was horrible. But either way, for sure its still tough to say for reasons you mentioned and Tai definitely had things going for him himself.Thing is people's perceptions now on how they'd have voted versus then out on the island are likely different. I think you vote with more emotion during the game and Tai the one time refugee florist versus the professional athlete personal injury lawyer millionaire would only need to have flipped one of the what if votes on finale night. All those who said "Tai" on the reunion would likely have voted for him on the island as well, so just need one of the Brad votes to flip.
The reunion voters opinions are influenced by the show editing - they see a lot of what they didn't personally see on the island afterall and given Brad was F3 and was sold as the only other viable winner and thus needed a decent winners edit.
Too many twists on this season. I mean how can it be a game if you don't know the friggin rules when you start playing it. Season blew up on the botched two tribes one tribal where Malcolm went home. That fuck up led to JT's boot as well and very likely Sandra not making the jury at the very least. They have so many pre-merge tribe swaps now to prevent strong alliances forming and majority just picking off minority one-by-one with surgical precision. That makes for boring seasons, but I think this season went too far in trying to mitigate that happening.
Yeah new Final Tribal format was cool, it allowed for more back and forth. I felt kinda bad for Troyzan who must have quickly realized he wasn't in the running. He handled it well though.
I was a bit surprised at how bitter people were acting toward Sarah but I guess that reflected the tone of the entire season i.e. everyone was going hard all season and seemed to be taking everything is really seriously. Sarah played a great game though and totally deserved to win.
One quibble... Sarah still didn't play the vote stealer advantage correctly. Michaela was voted out 4-2-1. The extra vote was taken from Tai and if the vote hadn't been stolen at most it would have been 3-2-2. This was simply the first time that the stolen vote went towards the person who was eliminated.
Overall I thought this was an enjoyable but ultimately average season.