- Joined
- Jan 5, 2008
- Messages
- 9,767
- Reaction score
- 429
No. Vader becomes stronger post Mustafar. Not at first. He changes his movements obviously but he grows to become better in the force and dueling. Had he not been burned and maimed he would have been far stronger sure. But his appearance in ROTJ is him at the peak of what he can reach. Meaning ROTJ Vader would easily kill ROTS Vader. Hypothetical a non suited injury free Vader in the same time frame of ROTJ owns his suited self.
I think it's obvious that Vader has grown old and is less inline with the dark side by the time we hit ROTJ. He is surviving only due to the efforts of Palpatine keeping him alive, and as someone else said, Palpatine is only allowing him to become so powerful. You can look to the duel in Empire when Vader is chooses to switch locations, he lunges at Luke from out of nowhere. It's not hard to infer that he was out of breath and was needing time to recover. He then foregoes a physical battle and chooses to use his stronger force powers to attack Luke. No way in hell would Mustafar Vader have made that choice or have needed to make that choice. Remember, this is a Luke who had very little training in the force, let alone in saber combat.
Reading what I've typed here I find it hilarious that I'm actually having a discussion about this on an MMA forum at 3am. LMAO