Yea i suggested that they give out a couple for the guys to review i'm sure a few guys have some 10oz winning's to compare them to the heritage line but the suggestion was ignored and then some negative comments were given instead.
Well, nobody sent them for free, but since I have had both 14 oz. Winning and 14 oz. Heritage...
1) Materials
Leather
- I can assure the Winning leather is at least of an equally high grade, probably even higher. Heritage is just dyed in a different way.
- "Drum dyed" (Heritage) is a gimmick. Yes, it looks nice, smells nice. However unlike painted leather, this leather absorbs any liquid - not the oil only, but water, sweat, blood - of course, any of this more or less affects the future appearance.
- To continue the previous - unlike in case of baseball gloves it is very silly to use this leather for sparring gloves, THIS is the reason why almost nobody else use it, Darrin, not because it is fu***n good (and expensive) as you claim.
- For this reason Winning leather is much better and much more suitable for the purpose.
Padding
- Heritage are just an IMF, just like almost all Ringside gloves. Nothing more, nothing less. And it is absolutely unimportant whether it is a 20 or 18.375% softer/firmer IMF. Not much better than the precious IMF, not better at all than BAYFILL.
- Winning layered padding is a miracle. And this is not a gimmick. The level of the ABSORPTION is phenomenal, incomparable to any gloves in the world. Miles better than layered latex in Mexican gloves, miles better than IMF because IMF it basically a sort of a wall which prevents your knuckles going through. Of course IMF is usually more protective than soft layered latex.
Lining
- Heritage lining is nice, but personally I prefer Winning lining.
Vecro strap
- The quality is incomparable. Winning is M U C H better, Heritage has just an average one.
2) Fit
- Well, in Winning you need no effort to make a fist, they are simply the best in this area. In Heritage you of course do need some effort, they are IMF in the end - but it is not as bad as in many other IMF.
- The overall fit of Winning is much more comfortable and natural, the thumb in just Winning is perfect.
3) Craftmanship
- Supposed to be the flagship of Heritage as Darrin promised. It isn't. On my Heritage there are missed stitches (not a big deal in general since they are double stitched, but A BIG DEAL since they cost 200 bucks) and the stiching is a bit inconsistent and nothing to write home about in general. The stiching and the overall craftmanship of Heritage is pretty good comparing to the other Pakistani gloves, but absolutely fail comparing to Reyes/Grant/Winning.
- As was mentioned - Heritage are pretty good. Winning are a pure perfection.
4) Protection / Performance / Durability
- Well, Heritage are not bad in terms of protection / performance. I believe nobody who uses them is unhappy. HOWEVER comparison to Winning is ridiculous. It's like comparing the architecture of Rome in Georgia to Rome in Italy. Heritage are just nice IMF gloves, nothing more, nothing less.
- Knuckles protection and the way of absorption is certainly much better in Winning. Wrist support is not great in any of them (talking about velcro models), Heritage are a bit better though.
- Cannot comment the durability of Heritage yet. The durability of Winning is widely known.
5) The conclusion
- Heritage are probably the best gloves Ringside company's ever made (or at least during last years), they look fine, smell fine, perform fine. Very nice gloves.
BUT
- Heritage are light years behind Winning. Everything in Winning gloves is perfect. Most importantly the padding/performance are a class of their own.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
They are comparable only in terms of the cost, in EVERYTHING else Winning is MUCH better.
And a nice picture in the end. Have a look at the velcro strap of Heritage. Can you see the turquoise thing? It is most probably the material Ringside use for "soft palm" padding. To me it looks like a sort of sponge (especially the colour
). Ringside (with their "world class" craftmanship) are even too lazy to cover this fancy sh*t so you wouldn't be able to see it on the brown leather.