It isn't a straw man. People on here actually believe that if Muay Thai paid like kickboxing did, then there would be a sudden influx of foreign talent (who would otherwise be in kickboxing) who would dominate the weight classes. There is no other way to interpret their bullshit.
Back in the day, fools like
Brocktirement and
stmarcus used to claim that the Thai's weren't really by far the best muay thai practitioners from 145lb to 155lb, because the guys from Europe didn't try their hand at muay thai, because the money in kickboxing was so much better. But if they did then the Thais wouldn't looks so special. This is clearly factually inaccurate since many notable kickboxers from 145lb to 155lb have also done muay thai, and haven't ever accomplished anything notable. Not to mention the fact that there are foreign fighters who compete from 100lbs to 140lbs. What's their excuse? It isn't like there's another game in town for those guys. Kickboxing has only got going with consistent fights at 65kg relatively recently and next to nothing below that. And yet, surprise, surprise, no foreign fighters from those weight classes have accomplished anything in muay thai either.
And just the other day
Yodsanan,
Shadess, and
Snubnoze707 were claiming that kickboxers are not adequately represented at the highest levels in muay thai. This is because either they choose not to compete because the money in kickboxing is superior or because there is a conspiracy on the part of stadium promoters to keep the kickboxers from getting opportunities to fight elite thais, for fear that they would clean up. But I guess that if they did they would have comparable success to Thais in kickboxing? And that this was a clear double standard because kickboxing promoters often extend the olive branch to Thais to fight at the highest level, although they admit not nearly as much as they extend it to nonthais. None of this is factually correct for the same reasons Brocktirement and stmarcus are obviously wrong. Kickboxers do get to fight good thais in international muay thai all the time. There are almost no kickboxers who fight from 100lb to 135lb for the Thai promoters to prevent from getting high level stadium opportunities and even if there were the promoters would be totally justified in not bringing them in without proving themselves. Because when kickboxers fight good thais from 145lb to 155lb they get molliwopped, pretty much without fail. So there is obviously no reason to think that if there were kickboxers fighting from 100lbs-140lbs and getting opportunities against elite Thais that they would do any better. In fact there is good reason to think that they would do far worse, since the majority of the talent in muay thai is at those weights. This is very much in contrast to kickboxing where good Thais have done extremely well, despite the fact that the main divisions that they compete in is not where the heart of Thailand's talent is concentrated. Morons like Yodsanan, Shadess and Snubnoze707 aren't any different from Brocktirement and stmarcus, except that they actually believe their own bullshit. I guess that the Thai dominance of muay thai is just based on smoke and mirrors, after all.
See these threads for a sampling of the bullshit I'm referring to:
http://forums.sherdog.com/threads/muay-thai-is-too-overrated-on-these-forums.2699897/
http://forums.sherdog.com/threads/the-kickfighting-establishment-is-rotten-to-the-core.3499125/