For serious, I would like this to be successful. We've talked about this stuff before. I kinda didn't want to host it since I'm so strapped for time in general, but I'll help out any way I can.
I do have some very strong suggestions to consider:
It would probably be best format to have 2-3 or so specific hosts (maybe two for the primary discussion, and one person who has a specific segment they do), and then open up a call-in segment.
And like I said before, having a format ... even just as basic as like: 10 minutes of WWE weekly tv recap / discussion, 5 minutes of NJPW / TNA / ROH / US indies combined (just major headlines, maybe a segment of discussion for major NJPW / ROH news), 3 minute WWE major event predictions / recap discussion, 2 minute classic event review (First War Games, and/or first Survivor Series would have been great this month, or whatever), 5 minutes of call-ins (maybe up to 8 if a convo gets good), up to 5 minutes for indirectly-related wrestling news (Xpac getting busted at the border, Kamala's in the hospital, WWE 2K18 patch broke the game, etc, etc) ... this way if the call-in segment runs long by a couple minutes you're only cutting out fluff, to keep it at a tight 30 minutes.
I don't even know how you were doing it, but did you actually need people to appear on camera ? I really would suggest something like doing it on Skype, let people appear on camera or not as they choose.
