- Joined
- Dec 20, 2009
- Messages
- 11,493
- Reaction score
- 1
Got the book for this the other day.
Quick question for anyone that's watched this and Punisher... Which would you say is better?
Got the book for this the other day.
I had a similar feeling about the Envoy flashback episode, the worst one out of the whole season. Really weak, but overall the season was pretty good.I agree. The first 6 episodes I was like this is the best show ever. Then the flashback episode felt really cheap and the actors were pretty awful. Then I got really annoyed how everything ended up relating back to the main character. IMO it would have been much better if he was just a dude from the past solving a crime.
Carbon. Punisher didn't have enough punishing.Quick question for anyone that's watched this and Punisher... Which would you say is better?
I read the book and while admittedly it's been a while, I found the show confusing at times even while being familiar with the world and technology. I wish they would have explained why being an Envoy made Kovacs such a badass a bit better.
I wasn't a huge fan of some of the many changes they made in adaptation. Too many character mashups (where's Trepp, dammit?) and the origins of the Envoys and Falconer were a lot different. They could have kept her out of this season as a character entirely.
Casting seemed to be a mixed bag. Nobody was terrible, but many weren't as the book depicted or as I imagined them. Kinnaman was fine, but the other Kovacs were closer to the image I had. Ortega should have been Patricia Velasquez IMO, that tiny chick with huge comedy boobs wasn't believable in her role. The Bancrofts were fine though Miriam was a bit older than I imagined her.
TBH I could have done with a little less T&A (though in that aspect the show is pretty faithful to the book) It wasn't even HBO sexposition.
The book was better because it tried less to humanize Kovacs, but like the Punisher, I understand why they changed it.
7.5/10 and that's because I'm a Morgan fan.
Just finished. Some questions
So I guess he permadeaded his sister? It didn't really show where he shot her and her neck looked in tact.
Did it imply that his sister was sleeved into the blonde and banged him?
How's the book?Got the book for this the other day.
pretty damn goodHow's the book?
they're both shitty, but the Punisher is better because it has decent acting at least. Altered Carbon started off with a good premise but descended into a cheesy 90's style cringefest filled with philosophy 101 debate fodder and dated cyberpunk aesthetics. It felt more like a sci-fi adventure game than a well crafted story.Quick question for anyone that's watched this and Punisher... Which would you say is better?