My top 5 P4P all time great list.

[CereserBr]

1- Jones
2- Fedor
3- Anderson
4- GSP
5- Aldo

The 5th spot was thinking about MM as well, but decided putting Aldo.

What u guys say?

 

[Hidden_Hand]

Well those are undoubtedly the five greatest MMA fighters we have seen so far, I don't think you'll get much argument against that.

In what order they go is anyones guess really and you can make a strong case for all of them to be #1

For me personally I could make a strong case GSP is the single greatest actual MMA specialist we've ever had.

 

[NotSoSure]

1-Silva
2-Jones
3-Fedor
4-GSP
5-????

There is no 5th place right now.

McFraud fans showing up to cry in 3, 2, 1......

 

[wilKO]

Yeah those are the top 5. The order is debatable. Good list I guess

 

[chitoortiz]

1- Jones
2- Fedor
3- Anderson
4- GSP
5- Aldo

The 5th spot was thinking about MM as well, but decided putting Aldo.

What u guys say?

That's a decent list.

 

[Bubblun]

Who give a shit, respectfully.

 

[Dana_is_your_GOD]

I'd say Hong Man Choi is #1

 

[FEDORRULEZ]

I'd rather put conor instead of silva. How can you have a proven cheat as all time greatest?

 

[SMEGMA]

Get Fedor off your list and you're good to go.

 

[trident]

I'd say Hong Man Choi is #1

Don't try and be funny

It's cringe

 

[wilKO]

I'd rather put conor instead of silva. How can you have a proven cheat as all time greatest?

Jones is on the list too

 

[Sapp]

Solid list.

 

[Bokelj]

Small shuffle but good list.

 

[Fatback96]

Can't forget

 

[JustBleed69]

1- Jones
2- Fedor
3- Anderson
4- GSP
5- Aldo

The 5th spot was thinking about MM as well, but decided putting Aldo.

What u guys say?

I would go

1. GSP - Toughest weight class, best compeitition, never lost the belt, didn't test positive.

2. Anderson Silva

3. Jon Jones

4. Mighty Mouse

5. Fedor

Kind of laughable to have Aldo in top 5 and not mighty mouse imo

 

[wilKO]

I would go

1. GSP - Toughest weight class, best compeitition, never lost the belt, didn't test positive.

2. Anderson Silva

3. Jon Jones

4. Mighty Mouse

5. Fedor

Kind of laughable to have Aldo in top 5 and not mighty mouse imo

MM has 2 losses unavenged too. And his competition and who he has beaten is worse than Aldos so I think it's fair enough.

 

[FEDORRULEZ]

I'd rather put conor instead of silva. How can you have a prove

Jones is on the list too

I don't think jones at the end of the day was a proven cheater. Anderson clearly was .

 

[wilKO]

I'd rather put conor instead of silva. How can you have a prove

I don't think jones at the end of the day was a proven cheater. Anderson clearly was .

You don't think Jones was a cheater?

 

[NotSoSure]

I would go

1. GSP - Toughest weight class, best compeitition, never lost the belt, didn't test positive.

2. Anderson Silva

3. Jon Jones

4. Mighty Mouse

5. Fedor

Kind of laughable to have Aldo in top 5 and not mighty mouse imo

No way. Welterweight has always been mediocre. Jones and Silva are above GSP, also just based on skills and diversity.

 

[LilChuckLil]

1- Jones
2- Fedor
3- Anderson
4- GSP
5- Aldo

The 5th spot was thinking about MM as well, but decided putting Aldo.

What u guys say?

1- Jones
2-Anderson
3-GSP
4-Fedor
5-MM

IMO