- Joined
- Jun 13, 2005
- Messages
- 61,542
- Reaction score
- 25,534
It's a well-researched and relatively obscure list of films, but almost every film listed in the OP has elements of torture porn as their most stark and unsettling scenes.
I'm being a cuss, FYI. It's a very, very good list.
I haven't seen the Hungarian one. That intrigued me. I don't use the term "torture porn" to exclusively describe scenes of actual torture, or movies like Martyrs, either, which I think does as good or better a job than any film on the list of achieving an enduring psychological unease unrelated to the trauma of witnessing a recreated physical crime.
I'm talking about films like Irreversible, too, for example, that is best known for subjecting the viewer to prolonged scenes of gross physical crimes being committed. That one certainly is a classic, and deserves its ranking, but the most unsettling thing about it is the scene in the tunnel, not the nature of the errant vigilante justice.
The emotional/psychological drama is not the seat of what people find disturbing. It's not that I don't appreciate this approach. Dancer in the Dark is my favorite film of all time, and easily one of the most psychologically disturbing films I have ever seen in my life. But I think most are gutted by a particular scene with a fire hydrant.
Meanwhile, in films like Kids or Nobody Knows, you're not forced to witness appalling physical crimes.
For example, the enduring psychological unease from Peckinpah's Straw Dogs derives from whether or not his wife wanted it. It raises some of the most uncomfortable questions about human nature ever postulated in the history of film; about the specter of cuckoldry, the biological wisdom of jealousy, and the enduring dominant/submissive dimensions of human nature with regard to male-female interaction. It set feminists on fire.
Films like Stalingrad will fucking hollow you out from the inside. You'll never look at war the same way again. I saw Where the River Runs Black as a child, and I've still never quite recovered from the conclusion.
Another one? Neil LaBute's The Shape of Things. Man will that film torment the thinking man.
But for this post I will nominate another film that probably many of you have never seen. Good luck coming back from this. I'm not about to fuck up your day. This is going to fuck you up for a fortnight, at least, and it's PG-13. I'm coming at you like Jim Gaffigan comes at foul-mouthed comics:
Last edited:
