"Its harder to become an elite boxer than an elite mma fighter"

Not saying Rogan would win every time, but if someone had a gun to my head, I certainly wouldn't be backing Floyd.

If we're talking about someone like GGG then yes, the odds change quite dramatically in the boxers favour.
 
Why would he need to come off steroids? He legally takes TRT like a lot of older, athletic dudes do. I'll do the same too at that age if I can afford that shit.

...because he wouldn't pass any drug tests?

He gets credit for being a BJJ and Taekwondo black belt with plenty of competitive martial arts experience. Any martial artist who can kick like Rogan, whilst having a 40lb size advantage and a BJJ blackbelt would take my money in a fight against Floyd outside the ring.

I have a Tang Soo Do black belt and a height advantage, so I'd beat Joe Rogan's ass.
 
...because he wouldn't pass any drug tests?



I have a Tang Soo Do black belt and a height advantage, so I'd beat Joe Rogan's ass.

Whens the last time you took a drug test before a street fight?

Baltimore my arse.
 
Whens the last time you took a drug test before a street fight?

Baltimore my arse.

No street fights occur in Baltimore without proper Olympic style testing. It is a very noble and dignified city, we don't tolerate cheats like Joe Rogan.
 
No street fights occur in Baltimore without proper Olympic style testing. It is a very noble and dignified city, we don't tolerate cheats like Joe Rogan.

If it's not all year round random testing it don't mean shit.
 
The best boxer doing MMA right now by FAR is Yodsanan Sityodong, one of the Thailand's best boxers

57-3 (46 KOs) and multiple time WBA 130 world champ

http://boxrec.com/boxer/42255

Hes 3-1 after a few months of training, and even his only loss he dropped the dude with a short punch when that dude was going for a TD

 
The best boxer doing MMA right now by FAR is Yodsanan Sityodong, one of the Thailand's best boxers

57-3 (46 KOs) and multiple time WBA 130 world champ

http://boxrec.com/boxer/42255

Hes 3-1 after a few months of training, and even his only loss he dropped the dude with a short punch when that dude was going for a TD



If he has a strong grappling base he will do well, if he doesn't he will fail at the top to mid level.
 
The best boxer doing MMA right now by FAR is Yodsanan Sityodong, one of the Thailand's best boxers

57-3 (46 KOs) and multiple time WBA 130 world champ

http://boxrec.com/boxer/42255

Hes 3-1 after a few months of training, and even his only loss he dropped the dude with a short punch when that dude was going for a TD



thank god it's not boxing, at 3-1 he would be considered a has been.

Also floyd loses to rogan, his kicks alone would shatter floyds hands
 
Last edited:
thank god it's not boxing, at 3-1 he would be considered a has been.

Also floyd loses to rogan, his kicks alone would shatter floyds hands
Give me 128 instances that a boxer just starting out with a record of 3-1 was callled a has been

I'll wait

Look folks bet he can't show real proof

Will change he subject

By the way the answer is still yes

It's harder to become and elite boxer
 
Its funny how you people talk about one of the most talented boxers of all time gets beaten by a comentator. You really think Rogan lands a hit or takes down someone who understands and controls distance like Floyd? The guy builds a career on his boxing and fighting IQ but Rogan beats him. I am still gonna claim any top boxer at his prime is going to roll trough a couple of divisions without much problems. Guys like Ward, Kovalev, Golovkin, Lomaschenko will make fun of MMA fighters the way Cody made fun of Cruz.

All these claims are comming out of a person who has lived in a mafia country with wrestlers serving the boxers and being afraid for 20 years to fight them.
 
Its funny how you people talk about one of the most talented boxers of all time gets beaten by a comentator. You really think Rogan lands a hit or takes down someone who understands and controls distance like Floyd? The guy builds a career on his boxing and fighting IQ but Rogan beats him. I am still gonna claim any top boxer at his prime is going to roll trough a couple of divisions without much problems. Guys like Ward, Kovalev, Golovkin, Lomaschenko will make fun of MMA fighters the way Cody made fun of Cruz.

All these claims are comming out of a person who has lived in a mafia country with wrestlers serving the boxers and being afraid for 20 years to fight them.

Cody made fun of Cruz with his ability to keep the fight standing. Also gauging distance between punches and kicks is a different animal. Floyds and experience and muscle memory is all based on punches. Rogan would literally do nothing but spam kicks and bust up floyds arms and hands within a minute
 
Rogan wins because of his size. If Rogan was 147 and Floyd took TRT and Onnit then Rogan would get killed
 
Last edited:
Don fry gets killed by a boxer in a street fight at a casino , yet Rogan can beat Floyd ?

Oh and UFC fighter in Vegas gets destroyed by a civilian , yet Rogan beats Floyd ?

Rogan has zero fights in 5 years , he would have ring rust for one
Second Rogan is not a fighter



Oh and the answer is still yes to the op question
 
Cody made fun of Cruz with his ability to keep the fight standing. Also gauging distance between punches and kicks is a different animal. Floyds and experience and muscle memory is all based on punches. Rogan would literally do nothing but spam kicks and bust up floyds arms and hands within a minute
You think Floyd csnt judge the fistance of a kick and the ine combo knock down Rogan! You are out of your mind. I am pretty sure Floyd can win most MMA fighters in a MMA fight. They just dont have the IQ to get the fight in the ground. I am surpriced how people underestimate the ability of pro boxers. These guys are no random fighters. They are pro fighters with an insane cardio abd technique not some wrestlers wanna be stand up fighters.
 
He's not only a boxer. He had 50+ pro Muay Thai fights.

Also this video is interesting, it proves a low level athlete but skilled in his sport (Jiang Lung Yun) is able to put to sleep a legendary class boxer and muay thai fighter.
BJJ is really efficient in term of training to effectiveness ratio.

The best boxer doing MMA right now by FAR is Yodsanan Sityodong, one of the Thailand's best boxers

57-3 (46 KOs) and multiple time WBA 130 world champ

http://boxrec.com/boxer/42255

Hes 3-1 after a few months of training, and even his only loss he dropped the dude with a short punch when that dude was going for a TD

 
I think the whole Rogan subject isnt really worth discussing. Nothing good is gonna come out of that. As others have said,any specialized (and long established) sport is going to be harder to reach the top. I love boxing and mma,certainly enough room for both in my life...i just simply prefer the more "free form" expression of MMA,where there are more ways to win. I still love the things that boxing has that mma doesnt,the guy fighting to his feet to beat the count,and the long masterful unvelling of a gameplan only to have two knockdowns erase all the work put in. I also like how in mma its wholly up tp the fighter to escape the predicament he is in with no recovery time. I love them both,and see no value in demeaning one or the other. Its kind of stupid to compare them. They are so different.
 
In MMA you only really need to be okay at a bunch of different things with one "specialty" which will allow you to differentiate yourself; this is what has allowed for mediocre boxers and MT guys like Silva and Connor to effectively dominate the standup game and guys like GSP to grapplefuck their competition for years on end. It's a sport of inclusion wherein the required level of mastery for all its constituent components is significantly lower than in a specialized sport like boxing and any weaknesses in your game can be mitigated by crutching heavily on your strengths. What I mean by this is that you don't need to be a good wrestler, a good striker and a good submission artist to be successful in MMA, in fact you could be a terrible striker, a terrible wrestler and a good grappler and be UFC champion (I'm looking at you Honda). In boxing you have to be at the bare minimum good at all aspects of the sport with at least one area where you excel to even be considered a contender and this is due to the depth entailed by a sport of reduction. In MMA you could conceivably achieve a competitive familiarity with the ground as well as the striking game even if you are not especially talented or athletically gifted and oftentimes you can get by without any serious, nuanced knowledge of either aspect which is required to simply be competitive in boxing or really any specialized martial art.

Another way to think about is crossfit versus it's constituent components; the average games competitor does not possess strength or endurance beyond what's achievable by a regular person with a few years of training. And while it's impressive that they can run a few miles and also do some ugly cleans afterwards I guarantee you that maybe one out of every 100 "elite" level crossfitters is even genetically capable of achieving the same level of mastery in marathoning/triathloning, or even approaching world record numbers in weightlifting or powerlifting.

TL;DR: MMA sets the bar lower for each of it's constituent elements which means that there are fewer barriers to entry into the sport and the skill ceiling is significantly lower because all these elements lack depth.
Well said. Simply said in mma if you face a better boxer you still have many tools to fall back on to even the odds. In boxing if you face someone who is a better boxer your screwed for the most part.
 
yes, the skill level in boxing is way higher than the skill level in mma, currently.

in another 10-20 years were going to have the first generation of mma fighters that grew up doing it as kids. The goal in mma is to be well rounded, currently most guys are a B or C all the way around, or a A in "something" and a C everywhere else.

To make it in boxing you must be the creme of the crop. its extremely competitive.
 
Back
Top