Nein.
I had the Rival Traditional Training Headgear when I took the shot. The Rival headgear has significantly less passing than the R9. I ordered the R9 somewhat impulsively after I got out of surgery. I actually haven't used the R9 yet because I'm still recovering, but compared to my previous headgear it seems to offer substantially more protection—especially to my eye area.
I'm planning on getting the Winning FG5000, eventually, but that might change depending on how UMA's FG5000 model turns out or how reviews of the Sabas face saver turn out. Now that I have a bunch of hospital bills, though, I think paying the extra cash for the protection is maybe a smarter investment in the long run. I wish I had purchased the Winning FG5000 (or at least had my R-9) earlier. Since I didn't, I have to deal with bills, double vision, and a numb face...