Gsp defended the title 9 times,beat better competition and people still think fedor is greater?

[mjoln]

better competition? imagine prime Fedor vs Hughes / Penn / Diaz etc and GSP vs Mirko / Big Nog / Schilt

 

[SirKratos]

Fedor didn’t get KO’d in his prime

Yeah he did, unless you are gulllible enough to believe a fighter is out of prime once he start losing lol

 

[thobra]

GSP is great, but I don’t think it is comparable.

Fedor went 30 fights, ten years undefeated at HW. That is kind of special, you know.

 

[Icecreamguy]

Fedor would beat up gsp, so no. Do you even know the point of fighting? Its to the beat up the other guy. Gsp cant beatup fedor but youre calling him greater. Youre an idiot.

 

[Huligani]

People just have favorites. Is normal.

 

[Leone510]

Who is saying Fedor is greator? You see what I done did right there?

 

[JBJISGOAT]

Nobody honestly thinks that anymore. Fedor fanboys are the only ones that think that. Check out the latest GOAT poll in my sig, GSP won by devastating fashion. GSP has 18 top 5 wins, while Fedor doesn't even have half as many. GSP beat every man he faced, while Fedor lost several times to cans. FACTS!

 

[JBJISGOAT]

Fedor, a small HW, was undersized throughout his career and made a career out of fighting HWs.

GSP, a huge WW, was always the bigger man throughout his career and made a career out of fighting LWs.

View attachment 342149

LOL you why dont you use a picture of when Fedor was "in his prime" like his fanboys like to use, not of a recent pic.

Anyways:

Same size as Cain.

Oh yea, such a LHW lol.

 

[giusti825]

Fedor had the UFC Lineal HW title for 6 years and in that time defeated 5 former UFC Champions.

He finished the vast majority of his opponents and was ranked #1 at HW for 7 years, despite being small enough to cut to LHW easily.

This is a feat that will never be replicated. Fedors skillset also seemed more polished, effective and aggressive. He didn't need to gameplan to his opponents weaknesses, he could beat them at their strengths.....

 

[3sumrock]

Wow people seriously think Gsp is big as fedor?

 

[truthisfreedom]

gsp defended the title more than fedor and beat better competition and people still think fedor is greater?and not to mention,fedor got more losses

Beating someone the way GSP beat people (needing points, scorecards and judges), is nowhere near the level of actually BEATING opponents the people like Fedor, Jones and Silva did. IE, beating your opponent so bad, that they can't finish the fight.

I think you know that.

 

[Greco_Wiz]

This is why Pride fanatics just aren’t taken seriously. They’re as bad as the extreme casuals on the other side of the spectrum who argue Lesnar and McGregor as GOATs.

Instead of giving an honest evaluation of performances and a career, it’s nothing but retrospectively mapping a career to fit a “prime,” to void out any bad performances.

Fedor had an amazing career. He’s a HW goat. He doesn’t belong in the same sentence as GSP though.

 

[JBJISGOAT]

GSP would've died fighting against Fedor's competition.

Well Fedor fought at 230-240 lbs, GSP in his prime was like 185-195 lbs max. Fedor was thick as hell, I dont get why you fanboys do not get that!

 

[truthisfreedom]

Jones and unfortunately Andy is out in my list of Goats due to PEDs

They're all on steroids.

 

[vry pwrful]

Fedor finished fights

a win is a win, it's a sport. how dominant the win is, is kind of irrelevant if you're trying to judge the greatest objectively.

 

[truthisfreedom]

You guys come up with the most ridiculous, thin nonsense.

He didn't quit when he tore his groin fighting Alves.

He didn't quit against Hendricks, he fought his ass off until the final buzzer, which is why he won that fight.

He retired, not because of that fight, but for his own reasons, which he had hinted at for two years.

He is without a doubt the greatest champion the UFC has ever seen.

Lol yeah, because not finishing an opponent in your own weight class for 11 f*cking years, is "greatness" LOL

 

[chubbman]

*greaterer

 

[giusti825]

GSP made BJ Penn literally quit on the stool.

 

[Loiosh]

Lol yeah, because not finishing an opponent in your own weight class for 11 f*cking years, is "greatness" LOL

Beating every single fighter you have ever faced, at his level of competition, is pretty much the absolute definition of greatness.

 

[JBJISGOAT]

better competition? imagine prime Fedor vs Hughes / Penn / Diaz etc and GSP vs Mirko / Big Nog / Schilt

So bigger is better? Dog shit poster.

Imagine GSP 40 lbs bigger like Fedor was, and JUICED to the gills like Fedor was most likely since he fought in PRIDE where they promoted roid usage and would never think about testing.