Greatest MLB player of all time. (Pitchers excluded)

[Rygu]

It's hard to compare pitchers to those who aren't, so who is the best player in MLB history besides pitchers?

If I forgot someone who you think should be on the list (and I probably will) let me know and I'll add them.

 

[Bamboozled]

Babe Ruth pitched tho

Also, it's Rickey Henderson

 

[Corona]

Mike GOAT

 

[SportsBarGod]

Mike Piazza
Steve Garvey
Ron Cey
Kirk Gibson
Duke Snyder(by far the best outfielder in NY those days)

 

[Revolver]

going to laugh if someone mentions some fat can who played against dudes who needed a day time job.

 

[ignorant MMA fan]

going to laugh if someone mentions some fat can who played against dudes who needed a day time job.

Why you gotta talk about John Kruk like that?

 

[ignorant MMA fan]

It's hard to compare pitchers to those who aren't, so who is the best player in MLB history besides pitchers?

If I forgot someone who you think should be on the list (and I probably will) let me know and I'll add them.

Surely Mickey Mantle deserves consideration ... and my vote.

 

[Rygu]

Surely Mickey Mantle deserves consideration ... and my vote.

He was in my head when I was making the list I'm surprised and ashamed I didn't put him in.

 

[HeirApparent]

Barry Bonds

And in before the mouth breathers come in here and say "durr steroids" "Durr cheater"

 

[faustian]

Jose Canseco is the GOAT

 

[PlayswellwithLawnDarts]

 

[RR]

Bartolo Colon is the only answer

 

[Corona]

Barry Bonds

And in before the mouth breathers come in here and say "durr steroids" "Durr cheater"

Bonds is undoubtedly the best hitter of all time when you don’t consider steroids. Even if you take pre juice bonds he was an animal. But the juice elevated him to godly levels.

 

[My Spot]

It's hard to compare pitchers to those who aren't, so who is the best player in MLB history besides pitchers?

If I forgot someone who you think should be on the list (and I probably will) let me know and I'll add them.

Should've excluded cheaters.

 

[My Spot]

Bartolo Colon is the only answer

Jeff Conine.

 

[ignorant MMA fan]

I gotta go Ted Williams to be the greatest hitter.

 

[GSP_37]

I re-watched the MLB Network Special on Ted Williams .406 and someone suggested no one will hit .400 again due to the modern game using elite specialist relievers.

For speed and power and clutch, has to be Barry Bonds. I'd like to see Trout get a chance for clutch big hero moments for all the marbles.

 

[PlayswellwithLawnDarts]

Jeff Conine.

Tom Glavine

 

[wlu.29]

Fred mcgriff

 

[SammyPops]

Johnny Bench not on the list?