Nobody mentions it....but I've always suspected GSP vs. Serra as being a little shady, in reality. Think about it, you had your 2 winners from TUF Season 4 getting title shots.......TUF is in a sense, a much bigger hit that most PPV's at that time, would you not want an underdog story winner happening, to further advance the popularity?? Plus, Serra was definitely a stand out figure on the show, due to his personality, coaching ability. Lutter was on the other side of the bracket in the MW title fight, and there was just no personality/marketability there at all.
+GSP is head and shoulders on a different planet at that time, over everybody in the division, including his potential biggest threat, Matt Hughes.
++Hughes and Serra had huge beef on the show. Most casuals would rather see a fight between the 2, from spats on the show, rather than GSP, who wasn't as present as often on the show. Plus....low and behold.....Hughes just had to win 1 fight after losing the belt, later scheduled with Chris Lytle, to get the next title shot. TUF following up just a couple of seasons later then featured Hughes/Serra as coaches, when Serra was still champ, due to the beef. (Much more interesting seeing these 2 verbally spar, than GSP would have been in Hughes place.)
+++If you watch the fight, Joe and Mike kept commenting on how "heavy handed" Matt Serra was, and how much KO power he possessed.....but guess what.....Serra had NEVER KO'd or stopped an opponent due to strikes before this fight, even in the LW Division. (He had a stoppage of Pete Spratt on the TUF exhibition fight due to strikes, no sanctioned fights at all.) Plus, he had just scrapped by Chris Lytle on the TUF final by split decision.
++++Wasn't it easy to think that GSP would easily get his belt back?? He was too young, too good at that time, and actually has no losses on his record since the fight. Dana White repeatedly blamed his loss on "GSP not having his head in the game." We all knew GSP would be a star fighter for years to come, and his overall game at that time kind of changed the game in MMA. Isn't it possible, he might have been given an incentive to "not be on his game" for the evening, knowing that he would rebound, and possibly be admired more for his determination to regain the title he knew was his, and thus receive more sponsors/compensation/star power in the future (which he did)??
Just putting this out there........that fight never set with me as being 100% legit, something just didn't look or seem right to me, but theories abound everywhere. I saw this situation as a rising, young star, complying with the company, for the promise of much more wealth/benefits/recognition in the future for helping the company out this one time....but who is to say????