Discussion in 'UFC Discussion' started by Fesaine, Dec 6, 2018.
Yeah it doesn't really phase me, but I understand how it bothers alot of people.
Shhhh, don't tell people that Anderson had holes in his game and that his offensive striking was the only standout aspect of his game (but that was wayyyy ahead of any of his competitors). His defensive guard is the next best part of his game. His striking defense is hilariously overrated on this forum because he did that thing with Griffin where he falls into the same pre-set bob and weave routine he's used multiple times against slow fighters. The guy was tagged by some pretty questionable strikers multiple times but had a godly chin so relied on that: Fryklund, Chonan etc all landed solid shots on him.
I dont quite get when people call the division he fought in weak, but yet ignore the fact the the guys he did fight were top level MWs. I understand that MW dind't have the depth when Anderson got his belt, but if he's fighting top level guys then what difference does it make?? WW can have 25 top level fighters, while MW only has 10, but if both champs face the same amount of high level comp then what does depth matter?
I mean Anderson won the belt in 2006 and he first few fights were Franklin, Lutter, Marquart, Franklin and Hendo. That is 4/5 top level MWs, Lutter was average. The middle of his reign was weaker with Leitas and Maia, but then went Sonnen, Vitor, Okami, Sonnen which again are top level MWs.
Anderson and GSP fought pretty much an equal level of competition. Jones fought the best IMO
I feel that the other GOAT candidates fought much better opponents than him, that's all. Rich Franklin was a guy who's main strength was striking and his striking was really not great imo...
He may not be THE goat but he is certainly A goat at 185
Many don't see Rich as a elite fighter, but his resume speaks for how good he is. I don't think Anderson resume is better than the other goat candidates either....I think its on par with GSP, better than Fedor but not as good as Jones. I just wanted to point out the the depth of the MW division is not really some thing that hurts his legacy because he fought all the best guys the division had to offer.
DC has been ever since he ko'd stipe , and its stipe now now Stipe because DC fucked his shit up
homeboy popped 2 or 3 times wtf you talkin bout
My only critique with Jones is that he seemed to lose a lot of his fighting time to bullshit outside of fighting. Fighting isn't kind to folks who get older and eventually everyone makes the sacrifice to the JBG. I don't think Jones fought enough for his accolades to outweigh the eventual failures that will come later in his career. We are getting an older Jones with a bad hairline now. I hope he does perform well for his Gus fight and fight a lot more.
I know Anderson has been busted for steroids as well but that is later in his career after his horrific leg break. Anderson did give us a lot of fights while he was "hot".
I can shut this one down real quick. Did jones move up a weight class to fight anyone? Bye felicia
You gotta give Silva credit for always being willing to step in and save a card no matter who it’s against or how short notice.
He also had favorable matchups doing his run and as soon as the division started getting decent wrasslers who can actually get him down (not submission artists first... take down artists 10th like the luters of the world and all those sloppy brawlers his style was tailer made to destroy) he has problems right away... by first getting dominated for 4.5 rounds then pulling off a lucky ass sub and then shorts grab cheated in the Chael rematch on the way to that win.. and then he got “the crised” after 1 last free bum win vs a passed out in his car getting citizen arrested boner. Anderson has never faced an actual legit striker. Even TRTor just throws in a straight line with speed but nothing that’s actually technical. Hendo had pretty much completely lost his wrestlers ability by the time they fought so that defaults back to the sloppy brawler matchup that favors Andy.
Guidelines like that won’t give guys like BJ and Randy, both Top 10 of all time, their due.
Jones is way better than Anderson. Was that hard to understand?
Calm down sweetheart you'll give yourself headache
The insane stuff Silva did before loosing is unreal... such dominance and confidence... al the never seen moves... truly a pionier and 1 of a kind... Jones is nowhere near the unreal stuff Silva did...
Without eye pokes and the threat of them Jones wouldn't have won against many of his opponents. He is the only one of the beforementioned GOATs that constantly relied on using banned techniques.
Imagine if GSP or Fedor had went for multiple blatant groin kicks every fight. Would you still have called them GOATs? Because I wouldn't have.
Clean Goat: GSP
Roid Goat: Jones
Clean Wmma Goat: Gina/Ronda/Holly tied
Roid Wmma Goat: Cyborg
Potential GOATS w/PEDS
Potential GOAT w/o PEDS
Everything else is up for debate
This. We have never seen a more dangerous fighter than Jones.
Separate names with a comma.