Enforcing neutrality in the classroom

Teppodama

A Dude, playing a Dude, disquised as another Dude
@Silver
Joined
Dec 19, 2014
Messages
11,774
Reaction score
5,322
New York Teacher Disciplined for Anti-Trump Vocabulary Assignment

A teacher from a Staten Island, New York school has been disciplined after giving her students a vocabulary assignment that contained an anti-Trump question.

Adria Zawatsky, a veteran sixth-grade English teacher at Paulo Intermediate School (I.S. 75) received a letter of reprimand following a meeting with the school’s principal, Kenneth Zapata.

Zawatsky, who earns a six-figure annual salary, was disciplined after parent Vincent Ungro of Annadale reported to the Staten Island Advance that his 11-year-old daughter brought home a vocabulary assignment with the following fill-in-the-blank statements:

“President Trump speaks in a very superior and _________ manner insulting many people. He needs to be more __________ so that the American people respect and admire him.”

The choices students were given to respond to the statements were the words, “haughty” and “humble.”

A second statement which read, “Barack Obama set a _________ when he became the first African American president,” was supposed to be completed with the word “precedent.”

Ungro instructed his daughter not to complete the three statements regarding Trump and Obama. He added his own hand-written note to the teacher on the assignment that read, “Please keep your political views to yourself and do not try to influence my daughter.”

Zawatsky reportedly deducted 15 points from Ungro’s daughter’s grade for the missing words and added her own note:

Firstly, I do not believe I was expressing a political view at all on my vocabulary sheet. My reference to President Trump was about his personality traits rather than his ability as a president.

The media is nonstop on very similar references. This is considered freedom of speech and I feel I have the same right as they do.

“We have clear standards and regulations in place to ensure school staff maintain neutrality with respect to their political beliefs while in school,” said education department spokesman Michael Aciman.

Ungro said the teacher “should have known better” to avoid political references and should have at least apologized when the issue was raised with her.

“First, I don’t think that putting your personal feelings about politics into a sixth grader’s homework is proper,” Ungro said. “There were at least a thousand sentences that she could have used besides disparaging our president.”

The parent added that his daughter learned a valuable lesson from the experience.

“That she should stay strong with her beliefs even if it’s not the beliefs of her peers,” he continued. “That you don’t have to block traffic, wear silly costumes or destroy other people’s property to be heard. Through patience, persistence and the power of the pen, you can accomplish many things.”

Excellent stand by the parent and good job on the school for acknowledging that partisanship has no place in the classroom.

http://www.breitbart.com/big-govern...disciplined-anti-trump-vocabulary-assignment/
 
Ivy League Student Claims Classroom ‘Trauma’ After Professor Refuses to Acknowledge White Privilege

University of Pennsylvania student James Fisher took to the Ivy League school’s student newspaper to complain that a professor’s refusal to acknowledge white privilege was a traumatic experience for him.
Fisher claims that fall 2016 semester was his worst semester at the University of Pennsylvania — because a white professor refused to acknowledge his privilege.

Last semester was honestly the worst semester I’ve had at Penn so far. And all because of one thing: the white professors I’ve had at Penn. It appears that the term “privilege” does not apply to them. Nor do they care to learn what it is.

After one of his professor’s refused to acknowledge his privilege, Fisher claims that he was unable to attend that class for a month, saying he “did not want to step foot into another white space until I made sure that my mental health was restored.”

Fisher detailed his experience in the classroom, claiming that the professor, a “white man from the suburbs,” cultivated a classroom environment that caused him trauma.

Unfortunately, he proved my suspicions to be true. There were countless times that his lack of acknowledgment of his privilege led to some of the trauma that I experienced in class. He would show images of slaves on plantations and even allow students to say ignorant comments in class.

Fisher claims that he confronted the professor after class, telling him that lack of awareness of personal privilege had caused him racial trauma.

I remember having an intense conversation after class. I basically told him that what he was doing was traumatic to me, and as someone who has experienced a lot of racial trauma in his life, I would not allow him to continue. He then used the argument that, in order to make the class a “safe space,” he had to protect the voices of all students in the class.


"He then used the argument that, in order to make the class a “safe space,” he had to protect the voices of all students in the class." Excellent job on the part of the professor.

http://www.breitbart.com/tech/2017/...essor-refuses-to-acknowledge-white-privilege/
 
I think ill start using womens bathrooms, pretty sure those are cleaner. Whoever disagrees with my decision is getting touched with the jab for being literally Hitler.
 
Ivy League Student Claims Classroom ‘Trauma’ After Professor Refuses to Acknowledge White Privilege


"He then used the argument that, in order to make the class a “safe space,” he had to protect the voices of all students in the class." Excellent job on the part of the professor.

http://www.breitbart.com/tech/2017/...essor-refuses-to-acknowledge-white-privilege/
That Breitbart article is just trash. Someone probably spent 2 minutes on that. The original source is 1000 times more entertaining. http://www.thedp.com/article/2017/01/james-fisher-privelege-does-not-exist-to-white-penn-professors

I kinda feel sorry for that guy. No sort of pep talk is going to help him.
 
That Breitbart article is just trash. Someone probably spent 2 minutes on that. The original source is 1000 times more entertaining. http://www.thedp.com/article/2017/01/james-fisher-privelege-does-not-exist-to-white-penn-professors

I kinda feel sorry for that guy. No sort of pep talk is going to help him.
You're right, that guys full detailing of his "ordeal" was much more entertaining. You could really feel the pathos as well as the fear and rage. So strong, such a stance. :rolleyes:
 
You're right, that guys full detailing of his "ordeal" was much more entertaining. You could really feel the pathos as well as the fear and rage. So strong, such a stance. :rolleyes:
You know it's good when you have to check the source multiple times to make sure it's not satire.
 
I don't really see the issue with that question or sentence.
Sounds more like an educational question and not an anti-trump agenda.

A lot of noise over nothing.
 
I support neutrality enforcement in public schools. Public school is a place where kids should be taught to THINK and learn for themselves. To be presented with facts and allowed to form their own opinions (but unfortunately the kids opinions are often just parroting what their parents say).

This to me includes students in Chicago (liberal) not being told by a teacher that Trump is bad based on opinion. But also students in Texas (conservative) not being taught Creationism in a science class.
 
Back
Top