Does BJJ Work In Real Fighting?

What the fuck are you talking about you dipshit?

Seriously, you morons are just digging yourself into deeper pits of stupid every time your fingers touch a keyboard.

Have you ever heard of pulling guard? Have you ever seen someone get a standing kimura? Standing back-mount? Standing arm triangle?

For fucks sake I wasn’t making that stupid argument you posted at all. What the fuck is wrong with you mongoloids? It’s like you never even learned how to read.

Seriously, you don’t know shit. People train from standing all the fucking time in BJJ. It’s not theoretical you nitwit.

And no one is making the argument that all you need is BJJ anyway. I certainly wasn’t.

May I remind you that this is MMA. All these guys are training all this shit, all the time.

But don’t train BJJ at all and see how that works out for you. Even if you trained really good TDD you’d still be practicing BJJ because takedowns are not limited to just wrestling, they have been part of BJJ since it’s fucking inception.

Please delete your account and stop watching this sport. You’re a fucking disgrace. Fucking ‘05 account spouting such idiotic drivel.

You’re a really sad comment on the knowledge level of long term fans.

You need to calm TF down. You think Bjj spends a lot of time drilling standing kimuras these days? It doesn't. Maybe it used to, 10+ years ago when it was geared towards MMA.

Do you train both? I'll bet you don't. Have you sparred high level practitioners in both boxing and Bjj? Didn't think so. Things are different now.

Bjj is easy as hell to stall and beat the sh*t out of them while they try to get position. They know nothing of mobility or angles while standing because they don't practice them anymore, and very little when they did.

Takedowns are the specialty of Wrestling and Judo. Bjj'ers are notoriously sloppy at it. They haven't been taking anyone down in MMA for years. Wrestlers have.

If you trained a fraction as hard as you talked, you wouldn't feel a need to talk that way, "tough guy". It's a dead giveaway you don't have any idea what you're talking about, an unneeded clue due to the fact that what you say hasn't been relevant for a decade +.

Have a Great Day!
 
Last edited:
Get fucked, buddy.

1) never made the point that BJJ does not have limitations, or that BJJ is all you need.

2) people do train those things. Not to the extent they train other things, but you see shit like standing back-mount all the time. Reference Maia/Masvidal for a recent example.

3) takedowns have always been, and always will be, a part of BJJ.

4) this is MMA. Not boxing. Not BJJ. Sometimes things are effective, sometimes they are not. Nobody was saying any of this crap when Maia was back-packing everyone to bolivian.

For all these reasons that you failed to read in my posts, and the fact that you made up a bizarro arguement about TMAs or something, I respectfully reiterate that you are failure as a fan of MMA and should remove yourself in shame.

You seem do be doing a fine job fucking yourself and your sh*tty argument so don't let me interrupt you scissoring yourself, weakling puss.

1) The bizzaro argument is based on the thread title. It's the actual topic. Everyone knows that BJJ + other disciplines that work ... will still work. As will anything, including bicycling. "Does BJJ work in real fighting?" This implies Bjj by itself. Sorry you have to project your autism onto other people, hope it gets better someday.

2) Most BJJ classes do not train those things. MMA guys do, in MMA class.

3) Takedowns are the weakest taught part of BJJ and the grappling forum acknowledges this. If you want to learn the specfic art of takedowns, you need to learn from a takedown specialist (cross-training in either wrestling or judo, maybe sambo if its available) because they are not drilled well or regularly in Bjj classes nowdays, let alone by someone who has specialist abilities in that field. They get less attention than they did 15 years ago (which wasn't all that great back then), and yes I was there as well. Were you? No you weren't. You're pulling this out your ass.

4) Oh is it MMA? That's funny-- the title of the thread says BJJ in the context of real fighting. Real fighting implies self defense in a non-sport. You can make a different thread for MMA or you can even talk about it here if you want but it's not the actual topic. I guess you have only yourself to blame for that one. Let's talk about MMA for a second anyway-- Bjj has been doing horrible as of late. Bjj centric guys are all but nil these days. Only like 2 and a half of them even remain in the UFC, and none of them are close to being champion. When Maia (who is better at applying Bjj in MMA than everyone else and is a rockstar at it) uses his Bjj in MMA all he can do these days is stall. Bjj has hit a wall and is only getting less effective. The mystique is gone, everyone has learned its not hard to defend Bjj and that its much harder to defend against things like wrestling and boxing.

BJJ by itself used to be trained in context of self defense/MMA. Not anymore. You know who first brought these complaints about 6+ years ago? Not me, the Gracies themselves. Have fun arguing against that one! No doubt you'll try, but anyone reading this far can see there's really no point to it.
 
Last edited:
You need to calm TF down. You think Bjj spends a lot of time drilling standing kimuras these days? It doesn't. Maybe it used to, 10+ years ago when it was geared towards MMA.

Do you train both? I'll bet you don't. Have you sparred high level practitioners in both boxing and Bjj? Didn't think so. Things are different now.

Bjj is easy as hell to stall and beat the sh*t out of them while they try to get position. They know nothing of mobility or angles while standing because they don't practice them anymore, and very little when they did.

Takedowns are the specialty of Wrestling and Judo. Bjj'ers are notoriously sloppy at it. They haven't been taking anyone down in MMA for years. Wrestlers have.

If you trained a fraction as hard as you talked, you wouldn't feel a need to talk that way, "tough guy". It's a dead giveaway you don't have any idea what you're talking about, an unneeded clue due to the fact that what you say hasn't been relevant for a decade +.

Have a Great Day!

You sure do talk a lot considering it's just sound rasping out of your asshole.

Modern BJJ trains a ton of takedowns. Every week at a minimum two days devoted completely to stand up. And this is at a Gracie Barra where I train and it's the most all inclusive bjj gym out there.

And as soon as you hit blue belt the professor allows you and your sparring partner to start a roll from standing.

In short : you have this pathological hatered of bjj that is completely counter to a million examples out there.

Just go to YouTube and look up bjj in real life and tell me it doesn't work
 
WHAT'S BETTER?

BJJ OR GRACIE JIU JITSU?
GI OR NOGI?
 
whats real fighting? If youre on the ground and he is still standing, he will just kick you on the ground. But if both of you find yourselves on the ground, then yes, BJJ is absolutely applicable.

Unfortunately ive seen a lot of bar fights in San Diego. Lots of shirt pulling, and one guy will usually pull another guy down on the ground. Rarely do you see someone go for a legit takedown. Aint no one gonna double leg you in a real fight lol.
Exactly jits throws mess ppl up in the street. But I wouldn't take a street fight to the ground unless I was sure it was one on one or I was getting lit up aka panic wrestle lol
 
Ok, to end this debate. This is a gif of two BJJ black belts trying to take on Amature boxer with only 10 fights.
b6i7iKe.gif

This is a real life situation people. You roll around with your buddies on some padded mat in your karate costumes thinking your badass. When you got guys like this, who learn how to throw punches that shut your lights out on day 1. Spending hours sparring vicious Mexicans and shit, getting your head rattled, learning how to truly fight.
Boxing > BJJ
Who walks with their hands down chin up in a fight lmao these guys are absolutely retarded
 
A 40 year old amature boxer from Brazil. Name me one notable boxer from Brazil. Brazil can teach you how to commit crimes, but box?

Claimed he could box...

A DJ?

And crazy horse... a known ratard

Come on man. I showed you a video of a guy who actually knows how to box, taking out black belts. And you respond with that?
Acelino Freitas
 
Yeah, of course it "works", just like every other sport that models part of fighting. There are situations where it will be better to fight more like a boxer, more like a muay thai fighter, etc etc of course though - it's all valuable.
 
Did this thread get moved from the heavies? What’s going on in here?
Have you heard of the Gracie Family? They turned grappling into fighting. I don’t know of any good fighters who don’t know jiu Jitsu. The kind that was taught starting in the 1990’s.

As far as fighting goes, I would probably still rely on some hockey brawling. I’m learning some bo staff recently. My hockey stick is a lethal weapon.
 
Man! What a question.

The answer is yes. It works in real fight but not as much as we BJJ people would like to believe. The Gracie Jiu-jitsu that we saw in early UFCs and the one that was developed for street fighting was a bit different than what we are doing today.

In order to understand the difference you have to look at Gracie Combatives and other stuff that Gracie Academy is doing in Torrence that receives much ridicule here. I attended a seminar hosted by Royce Gracie and I was surprised at the differences between my BJJ and what Royce was teaching.

The guy spent a good half of the seminar in "closing the gap." This was all about how to close in and get the clinch against a slugger who is trying to knock your teeth out. It was straight out of UFC 1 and made me wonder why it was not part of my BJJ which begins from the knees? After that these guys went "rolling" and I felt that as a blue belt I would easily dominate their blue belt on the ground.

My conclusion was that if it was a BJJ submission match, our BJJ was superior to theirs but if someone started swinging punching then they were better prepared.

Having said that, most of BJJ schools also teach MMA and some striking as a separate class. The kind of strike defense and take downs Royce was teaching were much inferior to what a BJJ guy would learn in he starts cross training in these other disciplines at his own academy.

While Royce was dominating everyone in the last millenium, if todays UFC fighters were transported back in time to the early UFC days, they would do a better job than Royce does in early UFCs.

To answer your original question (which is a legitimate question no matter how much people take offense,) Martial Arts has evolved into the "third phase." First was pre-UFC era where "Kung-fu touch of death" and all that nonsense was the big deal. How well does it prepare you for a street fight? Since your opponent is also well versed in the same nonsense so you can be sure that it worked. Then came the UFC era and people realized that if you do not know ground fighting you can not fight. Taking the dude to the pavement was "the way." Now we are in the third phase where the stand up portion of Gracie Jiujitsu has evolved to become what you will learn in the striking class at your BJJ school. It will be a mix of Muay Thai and wrestling and will be superior to "close the gap and clinch" that Royce was doing.

Ground aspect of Original Gracie JJ has also evolved and become what you see on the mats in BJJ schools. This compartmentalization has enabled each aspect of BJJ to go beyond the original Gracie Jiujitsu. But, when you ask if a modern BJJ purist who only learns how to roll from his knees can really fight a real fight? It is a legitimate questions because Royce and Rickson may say NO! Personally I often find myself tapping to guys who would have no chance against me if I started swinging punches and kicks and it was an all out brawl. I guarantee you that.
 
Ground aspect of Original Gracie JJ has also evolved and become what you see on the mats in BJJ schools. This compartmentalization has enabled each aspect of BJJ to go beyond the original Gracie Jiujitsu. But, when you ask if a modern BJJ purist who only learns how to roll from his knees can really fight a real fight? It is a legitimate questions because Royce and Rickson may say NO! Personally I often find myself tapping to guys who would have no chance against me if I started swinging punches and kicks and it was an all out brawl. I guarantee you that.

This thread sucks balls and most replies are from morons but yours is balanced and thoughtful. I would say though if we look at the Gracie philosophy I think it wasn't about a smaller person destroying bigger people, it was about protecting yourself against the bigger opponent and not getting beaten up first, then winning. Helios matches would go forever, but he would protect himself until the opportunity presented itself, like Royce vs Severn.

Also like you say many schools also do train alot of self-defence/standup, with my former coach every class would stand with a standing technique. This notion that if you train BJJ all you know how to do pull guard is ridiculous. I can't wrestle much but it's a breeze to take down bigger white belts, if we add in strikes they're getting wrecked real fast as soon as we hit the mat. Few years back during one session at my gym a blue belt who couldn't wrestle a lick and a 2-stripe white who was an amateur boxer/kick boxer put on gloves and went at it. The blue belt had zero problems getting the takedown every time. It takes training to deal with these techniques, you don't just watch UFC and all of a sudden have a good sprawl.
 
BJJ does work in the streets, in a perfect 1 on 1 situation a BJJ student should be able to control the fight fairly easily. Arguably most street fights will go to the ground, giving the BJJ student a huge advantage. But most street fights are never a perfect 1 on 1 situation, most fights multiple people are-or-get involved when the physical altercations begin, especially chokes or joint locks. You've all seen when people fight back vs bully videos or road rage fight on camera. No one will interfere with a KO and followed up onslaught but as soon as a seasoned grappler gets a hold of RNC, everyone steps in "He's had enough!" "Let go, your choking him" but they stand by as a knocked out victim gets curb stomped. That really pisses me off actually. If BJJ gets into effect on the ground in a typical street fight, you can expect people to get involved really quick or worse the BJJ student goes to the ground to negate the attacker or whomever and gets stomped on by attacker/whoever's entourage is.
 
It def works. But it depends on the situation. If your in a crowded bar or outside a night club I wouldn't go for a take down and try and roll with someone in an attempt for a submission because odds are one of his friend is going to kick you in the face while your on the ground. It works in a 1v1 fight but in fighting like in life there is no guarantees. Lets say one guy is a purple belt and have trained BJJ 5x a week for 4-5 years is in great shape is 6-0 tall and 200lbs. The other fighter is a loud mouth annoying six feet tall 250lb a$$ hole who gets into a lot of fights and has heavy hands but has no martial arts exp. That fat a hole could knock out the purple belt with a lucky punch before he can get a chance to implement his game plan which would be taking the fight to the ground. Odds are if get to use your BJJ the BJJ fighter would win easily. I think the best solution is to do BJJ and some form of stand up fighting so you have an idea how to throw a punch, take a punch and block/dodge a punch in the event you cant get a take down right away or if the situation makes it not practical to take the fight to the ground.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top