- Joined
- Jul 1, 2013
- Messages
- 11,113
- Reaction score
- 1,081
In fairness to tony, he'd already earned the shot with the wins over Lee, RDA, Barboza, etc which are all legit. Got injured in the lead up to his legitimate title fight and still took another fight upon returning. Sure Pettis wasn't the highest ranked, but tony had already beaten all the other guys
Oh I defintely cut Tony slack because of him having been injured. Not as bad as BB for sure in terms of wins but it's hard for me to put all this weight in some of his wins especially his best wins.
Lee had staph and I thought that the conditioning was an excuse but his pace vs Barboza was night and day and Tony was getting pieced up by Lee(and outgrappled) who hadn't had a history of being a great striker.
Then poked RDA in the deciding round(in my opinion) of a competitive fight.
As well as getting pieced up by Barboza before and even some after the upkick that hurt Edson.
Lots of asterisks in his list of wins in my opinion. But with all the variables in MMA, I'm sure most fighters who make it to the UFC would have asterisk if you went through their careers with a comb. So who knows I guess.