Demetrious Johnson vs Anderson Silva vs George Saint. Pierre

[Mikey Tanisha]

Who is the bigger GOAT and why?

 

[BokaBokte]

GSP. Because reasons.

 

[QcChopper]

Silva got caught cheating twice, I can't ever consider him GOAT.
Mighty Mouse is behind GSP in my book, Georges has more title fight wins, no unavenged losses, fought better competition and is a 2 weight class champ.

 

[Flokk]

Nope nope nope.

 

[Ceez]

MM can't even get in their neighborhood

Not enough money

Not enough quality wins/level of competition

Not enough money

Too short

Ducked TJ to break the record

 

[Hypetrainofthemonth]

GSP/Fedor

 

[knspiracy]

Why do PED's matter? Are there rules to GOAT? Please specify the rules to the imaginary game before starting the game.

 

[ICEibuPROfen]

After Conor, the OFFICIAL GOAT, probably GSP

 

[The GIF Poster]

 

[Sapp]

GSP has the best case.

 

[20falarVerdades]

Demetrious Johnson has yet to surpass guys like Tony Ferguson and Max Holloway, he's not on Silva nor GSP's level. Fact. Inb4 people bring up "title defenses" in an imaginary division lmao

 

[Apollo1029]

GSP can't be goat because of his privilege.

Anderson is a cheater.

This only leaves DJ.

 

[Helden]

MM should not be included in discussions of who is the bigger anything

My vote goes to GSP, getting caught roiding does matter.. and disqualifies you from GOAT talk

GSP is also a 2 division champion

 

[The guest]

The Spider is out, buddeh.

If you pop, you can NEVER again be mentioned in any GOAT talk.

Sorry, but that’s the way I see it. And many people agree with that position about the thing. It’s nice to see honest ppl are raising the bar on shit like this.

 

[RockyLockridge]

Georges is the best. Roiders included.

with roids:
Georges
Fedor
Jones
Mouse
Silva

Without roids:
Georges
Fedor
Mouse
Aldo
Cruz