How are Cora and Peeby ugly? They are quire hot, especially Peeby's personality.
The criticism is overblown for this game. It's really good.
The game is good and I enjoyed 30h of it already. if I could make my wife and job screw off for a week and play - I would.
Criticism is overblown a bit, yes, but it stands on solid evidence.
Peebee looks like a slimmer hotter blue Amy Schumer. Also, her stripe of a makeup is very unflattering to her looks. I wouldn't call her ugly, but after Liara and Aria she is meh at best. And yes, she looks worse thanks to horrible animations (google Pebee Shrek for proof).
Female Ryder is not ugly, but is vastly inferior to a girl whose face they scanned and her animations are the worst - she looks mildly retarded at best and her mouth moves good 3 inches up and dowh her face. With proper animations she'd be the best looking girl on board imo.
Cora is a boise 7 - her jaw is twice as wide as male Ryder's, and she suffers from a severe case of ME:A puffy cheeks syndrome, but her ass is on point. Animations don't damage her looks so much.
Science red head girl looks nice and likeable, but animations spoil her looks a lot - her lips move so weird.
All asari in game except Pebee look the fucking same, including the Natalie Dormer one, Lexi or what-s-her-face - they all have the same face shape and puffy cheeks.
Most turian faces in the game look bad - they seem over - lightened and flat, also animations don't fit their lips. Female turians look a tad better than males.
Krogans and salarians look good - great scaly textures, best facial animations.
What also disappointed me a lot was the romance writing. Some dialogues with Pebee are so damn cringey! And the dialogues with Liam... Damn, we having a nice bro chittychat and then an option pops up captioned "I am interested in you". Is this suposed to show gays are so bland and just go for a quickie in an escape pod instead of getting just a bit involved with each other for starters? And if you're not planning on hitting on a character having such an option in dialogue is very disencouraging.
TL DR version: game is really good but unpolished. Could have been great with more testing and polishing the details (and a competent animation team, yes)