Did his numbers match up with the numbers released by WWE? I think that's all that matters here. Could care less what fans on some forum think people are fucking stupid and will mock someone just cause they are jealous. Half the people on that wrestling forum are probably pissed cause Meltzer makes a living off something they love to watch.
For the record:
Chael is a member of Meltzer's sitte (along with FRB) & what Chael actually said was:
The only person that is close on PPV numbers is Dave Meltzer - except mine which are always low.
Only a nitwit would not get the humor CS was going for.
You know the same humor where he says he was MMA's biggest draw & highest paid athlete?
Also like you said, his numbers were backed by WWE's financials that went public.
Sports Illustrated Senior Reporter:
“You could cover the Vatican or State Department,” Deford said recently, “and not do as good a job as Dave Meltzer does”
Ariel Helwani:
Pumped that Dave Meltzer, the Godfather of MMA journalism, is now a part of @mmafighting.
Snowden:
Every MMA journalist is the same guy except Dave Meltzer who is the guy they are trying to be.
As far as his respect in the industry of wrestling.
I'd go with Jim Ross, Flair, Hart, Cornette, Jericho, Rock, etc. over some cranky fans.
I disagree with his opinions on MMA a lot (more than I agree), but his history of business (MMA/WWE) is un-matched
He was the ONLY person to get all the UFC/WME sale details correct & is the only reason we have concrete evidence of what UFC financials are.
There are various kinds of reporters & when it comes to business, he is the best source by far.
Others are better at analytical breakdowns & interviews.