- Joined
- Aug 10, 2013
- Messages
- 25,249
- Reaction score
- 12,584
Should be fun...live now. Debate on ancient civilizations and the extinction event at the end of the last ice age.
Rogan is actually super on point today though he's being a bit one sided....his wheelhouse is calling out bullshit in general (despite his own) and Shermer is clearly full of shit to some extent today, mostly because he's taken on the persona of "Skeptic" to the point where he decided to debate someone like Hancock who has an enormously deep grasp on the subject that he himself does not.The frustration that's occurring within Hancock's dome during this discussion, is palpable.
Got tight when Shermer referred to him as "seeming reasonable" LMAO.
I think he has a sense that all alternative ideas are equally idiotic at some level...there is a big difference between Giorgio Tsukolos from Ancient Aliens and Graham Hancock (trying to debate Hancock on archeology, regardless of his endgame theories, would be a chore for long tenured professional archeologists let alone a novice like Shermer) and Shermer approached this like he was dealing with a nutjob without command of facts. Still worse is thinking he would be able to do anything regarding debating Carlson, who seems to even impress the most ardent of those skeptical of his conclusions with his borderline autistic level of unerstanding and field knowledge in the field of Geology and earth history.Lol why would Shermer even agree to this? I watched the first 2 hours and its been a one sided beatdown.
It was pretty funny how Shermer's geologist buddy seemed to be pretty damn impressed with Carlson by the end. But he still seemed to be pretty dismissive of Hancock. I never could understand why many people treat the lost civilization theory the same way as "aliens built the pyramids".I think he has a sense that all alternative ideas are equally idiotic at some level...there is a big difference between Giorgio Tsukolos from Ancient Aliens and Graham Hancock (trying to debate Hancock on archeology, regardless of his endgame theories, would be a chore for long tenured professional archeologists let alone a novice like Shermer) and Shermer approached this like he was dealing with a nutjob without command of facts. Still worse is thinking he would be able to do anything regarding debating Carlson, who seems to even impress the most ardent of those skeptical of his conclusions with his borderline autistic level of unerstanding and field knowledge in the field of Geology and earth history.
It was pretty funny how Shermer's geologist buddy seemed to be pretty damn impressed with Carlson by the end. But he still seemed to be pretty dismissive of Hancock. I never could understand why many people treat the lost civilization theory the same way as "aliens built the pyramids".
Drumlins and eskers bro...I follow the subject relatively well and the issue of the finger lakes being caused by such and such vs that and the other was completely beyond me. Randall's composite understanding of multiple disciplines seems to be impressive to even the most specialized scientists.When Carlson and the geologist were going DEEP into the geology vernacular I know Rogan was
That stuff flew right over my head for a good 5 minutes.
Are you skeptical of his abilities?How does Shermer even get invited to these things.