Stealing from King Fu bb -Just for fun: If you could change 2 "controversial" referee's decision....

Fluffernutter

Fluffernutter

Steel Belt
@Steel
Joined
Jul 16, 2008
Messages
27,000
Reaction score
18,841
If you could have the authority of a commission, which ref's decision would you overturn?
 
first 2 responses nailed it.

<45><Lmaoo><45><Lmaoo><45><Lmaoo>

/thread
 
You guys are harsh. Survival of the fittest on Sherdog.

I'm changing Rampage vs Forrest.
 
I'd change Rosenthal's decision to wait until Weidman had caved in Munoz's skull before stopping that fight. Stop it a dozen or more blows earlier. Save the guy some brain cells. Munoz was a good guy.

I'd also Bobby Green vs Krause, Green should not have been rewarded for smashing Krause's nadgers like that.

Know what? I'd change the finish of Warren/Curran as well. That was way too late.






Why is everyone crapping on TS? This isn't even a bad thead really. Why come on Sherdog just to be a douchebag? Surely one can be a douchebag and still talk fights, geez....
 
Bend NvR Break said:
You guys are harsh. Survival of the fittest on Sherdog.

I'm changing Rampage vs Forrest.
Click to expand...
Which part of the refereeing was bad in that fight? Can't remember bad reffing but haven't watched in ages.
 
Codpiece said:
I'd change Rosenthal's decision to wait until Weidman had caved in Munoz's skull before stopping that fight. Stop it a dozen or more blows earlier. Save the guy some brain cells. Munoz was a good guy.

I'd also Bobby Green vs Krause, Green should not have been rewarded for smashing Krause's nadgers like that.

Know what? I'd change the finish of Warren/Curran as well. That was way too late.






Why is everyone crapping on TS? This isn't even a bad thead really. Why come on Sherdog just to be a douchebag? Surely one can be a douchebag and still talk fights, geez....
Click to expand...

Munoz vs Weidman might be the worst stoppage ever.
 
takerfamous said:
Munoz vs Weidman might be the worst stoppage ever.
Click to expand...
Yeah it's the only mistake I remember Josh Rosenthal ever making. Munoz was absolutely prone and just being blasted while seemingly unconscious.
 
Not the worst, by far, but just to throw it out there, they stood rumble and vitor up extremely fast
 
Codpiece said:
Which part of the refereeing was bad in that fight? Can't remember bad reffing but haven't watched in ages.
Click to expand...
My bad. I'm kinda drunk. Rampage vs Forrest was bad judging not reffing.

Bad reffing was Cain vs Rothwell. Multiple times the ref could have stopped the fight but the actual moment the ref decided to stop the fight was stupid. Rothwell survived a beating and was standing back up when the ref stepped in.
 
Bend NvR Break said:
My bad. I'm kinda drunk. Rampage vs Forrest was bad judging not reffing.

Bad reffing was Cain vs Rothwell. Multiple times the ref could have stopped the fight but the actual moment the ref decided to stop the fight was stupid. Rothwell survived a beating and was standing back up when the ref stepped in.
Click to expand...
True, I kinda more remember the beating than the stoppage but I do remember Rothwell shouting "why?" after it was called off. Cain was like the terminator in that fight.


I used to think Rampage won, but I watched Forrest/Page again maybe two years ago and changed my mind. Rampage had a couple of good rounds but I thought under '10 point must' that Forrest was the right winner.
 
Codpiece said:
True, I kinda more remember the beating than the stoppage but I do remember Rothwell shouting "why?" after it was called off. Cain was like the terminator in that fight.


I used to think Rampage won, but I watched Forrest/Page again maybe two years ago and changed my mind. Rampage had a couple of good rounds but I thought under '10 point must' that Forrest was the right winner.
Click to expand...
Yeah I'm not saying Cain didn't dominate Rothwell but there was 3/4 times the fight could have been stopped and it wasn't.

I had Rampage 48-47. Outside the 2nd round all the other rounds could have been scored Rampage's way.
 
Bend NvR Break said:
Yeah I'm not saying Cain didn't dominate Rothwell but there was 3/4 times the fight could have been stopped and it wasn't.

I had Rampage 48-47. Outside the 2nd round all the other rounds could have been scored Rampage's way.
Click to expand...
Oh for sure, like I said the Rothwell stoppage was not great. It was a weird time to call it since Big Ben was moving to defend intelligently....guess I justified it in my mind by thinking about how Rothwell just had nothing for Cain in that fight.


If I ever watch Page/Forrect again I'll maybe hit you up if you want, let you know my thoughts?
 
Faber - Rivera is the only one that comes to mind at the moment. I'd DQ Faber for the intentional eye poke.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,236,655
Messages
55,432,376
Members
174,775
Latest member
kilgorevontrouty

Share this page

Back
Top