I have watched thousands of ammy fights.Some are good,some are what you'd expect,I have seen TONS that Phil would smoke.Just saying Amatuer means nothing,there's plenty of ammy's that would be solid pro's and there's tons of ammy's that have literally laughable skills/athletic ability,way worse than Phil.Really a meaningless question.If he fought only ammy's how would he do?Well is he fighting ammy's they dragged off a bar stool in Kentucky or is he fighting really good ammy's?If he was fighting strictly middle of the pack ammy's he'd probably do ok,win more than lose but still lose some.It's really hard to say with his idk 30 seconds of footage.Wait,why am I posting in a CM Punk thread?!Ugh got me lol.