In a world where....

[DatSamboKid]

McGregor beats Floyd
GSP beats Bisping
Aldo beats Holloway
Silva beats Gastelum
Fedor beats Mitrione
Demetrious beats Reis
and Jon Jones beats DC

What would be your top 5 GOAT fighters list?


For me,

N.1: GSP
N.2: Jon Jones
N.3: McGregor
N.4: Aldo
N.5: Silva

 

[DWAYNEAMERICA]

McGregor beats Floyd
GSP beats Bisping
Aldo beats Holloway
Silva beats Gastelum
Fedor beats Mitrione
Demetrious beats Reis
and Jon Jones beats DC

One of these things is not like the others...

 

[GrAtI]

Fedor
/thread

 

[UPAZWITTS]

In a world where Conor defends a belt, the list would look like this:
JBJ
Spider
GSP
Fedor
the Mouse.

 

[20falarVerdades]

Fedor
Jones
SIlva
Aldo
Cormier
GSP

 

[orangecuse]

Anyone else read the title in that deep melodramatic movie trailer guy voice?

 

[The guest]

If you've popped you're out of the GOAT discussion, imo.

GSP
Fedor
MM
Aldo
Garbrandt

 

[Lodewijkp]

My #1 is anyone who slams smack in a alley. #2 is cokeheadjones #3 is GSP because gsp defended the canadian coke kingpin in a lawsuit who provided jones with baking soda.

 

[Drake]

That's just too much...& one of those is a boxing match that doesn't apply to MMA.


Ya know. Since it's boxing...& not MMA.

 

[Drake]

If you've popped you're out of the GOAT discussion, imo.

GSP
Fedor
MM
Aldo
Garbrandt

Cody over Dom on the GOAT list......?

 

[woodsideQ]

McGregor beats Floyd
GSP beats Bisping
Aldo beats Holloway
Silva beats Gastelum
Fedor beats Mitrione
Demetrious beats Reis
and Jon Jones beats DC

What would be your top 5 GOAT fighters list?


For me,

N.1: GSP
N.2: Jon Jones
N.3: McGregor
N.4: Aldo
N.5: Silva

i mean P4P and GOAT is all opinion but more love for Silva

 

[woodsideQ]

Cody over Dom on the GOAT list......?

he whooped his ass didn't he?

 

[woodsideQ]

Fedor
Jones
SIlva
Aldo
Cormier
GSP

no GSP?

 

[woodsideQ]

That's just too much...& one of those is a boxing match that doesn't apply to MMA.


Ya know. Since it's boxing...& not MMA.

you beat a goat under his rule snad you get a bump from me....and i hate conor and hate his fans more but him beating floyd is like tom brady striking out mike trout

 

[Drake]

he whooped his ass didn't he?

In RD3&4. But still...his list doesn't have Conor over Aldo. Do you think it should? Would make sense going by that logic.

 

[woodsideQ]

If you've popped you're out of the GOAT discussion, imo.

GSP
Fedor
MM
Aldo
Garbrandt

i like your list alot except cody
at this point can't have cody...unless you have silva

 

[Drake]

you beat a goat under his rule snad you get a bump from me....and i hate conor and hate his fans more but him beating floyd is like tom brady striking out mike trout

I mean yeah he should get cred but the sports are too different. Take most any UFC fighter & put them in the octagon with Floyd & they'll take him down & beat him easily.

 

[woodsideQ]

call me crazy but anyone who left silva off i have to discount their list.
i'm biased but i'd have BJ Penn on my list too
I could even argue for Tito over some of these selections

 

[woodsideQ]

I mean yeah he should get cred but the sports are too different. Take most any UFC fighter & put them in the octagon with Floyd & they'll take him down & beat him easily.

sorry for the misunderstanding, i meant if conor beat floyd in a boxing match. if he beat him in MMA who cares

 

[Drake]

sorry for the misunderstanding, i meant if conor beat floyd in a boxing match. if he beat him in MMA who cares

No, I know.