My top 10 GOAT

[Cory Ellis]

10. Henderson
9. Werdum
8. Bj Penn
7. Mystic Mac
6. DJ
5. Fedor
4. Cain
3. Anderson
2. Jones
1. GSP

Obviously arguable just my opinion. What do you think?

 

[20falarVerdades]

LOL@ putting GSP at first when he didnt even finish fights, here's the legit top 5:

1. Fedor
2. Jones( has the potential to become #1)
3. Silva
4. Aldo
5. GSP

 

[G0DSPEED]

LOL@ putting GSP at first when didnt even finish fights, he's the legit top 5:

1. Fedor
2. Jones( has the potential to become #1)
3. Silva
4. Aldo
5. GSP

Jones is a cheater LOL. So is Silva.

That doesn't count.

 

[KOfinger]

Cain?

 

[Lacet]

Ok

 

[Toner]

Where is Aldo?

Jackass.

 

[20falarVerdades]

Jones is a cheater LOL. So is Silva.

That doesn't count.

 

[Cory Ellis]

I said 'obviously arguable'

 

[dickcheney]

was hoping for 10 pictures of goats

 

[whaleshark]

10. Dylan
9. Dylan
8. Dylan
7. Dylan
6. Dylan
5. Cody mckenzie
4. Dylan
3. Dylan
2. Goldie
1. New ring girls natty tig o bitties

 

[Rum]

10. Henderson
9. Werdum
8. Bj Penn
7. Mystic Mac
6. DJ
5. Fedor
4. Cain
3. Anderson
2. Jones
1. GSP

Obviously arguable just my opinion. What do you think?

Not having 9-defense champ Aldo in there?

Maybe the most embarrassing post in Sherdog history.

 

[13 others]

Houston Alexander
Cody Pfister
Tim Sylvia
GSP
Fedor
Vera
Johnny Hendricks
Bonnar
Anderson Silva
Kalib Starnes

(from 10 - 1)

 

[The guest]

My list would NEVER have a name on it of somebody that's popped for PEDs.

Some of those guys were all-time greats, and high on the P4P lists. But they can't be in the GOAT conversation.

GOAT candidates don't pop for PEDs. That's my honest belief. And it is NEVER going to change.

 

[mee-how!]

If you are listing 10, wouldn't Sakuraba be a lock?

 

[marksmen]

1. GSP
2. Anderson
3. Jones
4. Aldo
5. MM
6. Werdum
7. Fedor
8. Hendo
9. BJ
10. Conor

 

[EmeliankoFan1]

My list would NEVER have a name on it of somebody that's popped for PEDs.

Some of those guys were all-time greats, and high on the P4P lists. But they can't be in the GOAT conversation.

GOAT candidates don't pop for PEDs. That's my honest belief. And it is NEVER going to change.

GOAT candidates can be whatever the person making list deems them to be. If they got popped for dick pills or ass cream, so be it. Some of you like pushing your narrative as if it is someone else's narrative.

Getting popped for cocaine, weed, or Banned substances means sh1t, if these guys were still better than the rest of he crowd. A few people on the list never popped for
PEDs, it is assumed that they were on it, which could be false. An assumption is not a fact or true, it is an assumption.

Silvia was a beautiful fighter to watch and many of us consider him one of the goats. Jones was so good himself that he could snort cocaine during training and still beat championship caliber fighters. These men were the best I ever saw along with a list of others,