Impossible to say for sure, but I'd confidently bet on Cummins. Jones was a state champion in high school, while Cummins never placed, but Penn>>>>NY for wrestling. Though Cummins was Div I, his only years as an All-American were relatively weak years for heavyweight. Jones probably would've went to Div I if his grades were good (considering he was junior college champion), but who knows how he would've fared.
Big difference comes what Cummins did after college. Cummins was a pretty damn good ranked heavyweight, and senior USA is the big boys compared to NCAA just like the NFL. Too much of an experience edge here.
Weak as opposed to when?
Sometimes, hype just ain't enough.
Dana White on Strikeforce's decision to put [Herschel] Walker in the cage, "It's completely disrespectful to the sport." (2009)