2. name the shotakan karate kata and name the tkd pattern it copies , or better yet post a video of them so i can see for myself
3. just because the have front stance and low blocks and a kia on the end doesnt mean its the same pattern .
4. perhaps you are correct , as i dont know any shotokan katas or karate katas at all as to do the comparison myself
Quote:
Originally Posted by peanut66
5. and how did you become local karate champion if you dont even spar or hit pads ? just curious
1. See 2.
2. Take a look at the TKD poomse {post #64} @ the lower end of the list on your link.... then look @ the Shotokan kihon kata....
3. AH, what are you trying to accomplish? Get serious & have me to dinner along with Sinister.....
4. Do a little homework. Was going to put up a good vid, when I ran into "Answer Man" VVVV
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jukai
^^^ Jukes has done Shotokan for nigh on a decade, he's his thesis.... CARTOONS
Quote:
Originally Posted by peanut66
5. and how did you become local karate champion if you dont even spar or hit pads ? just curious
5. The part before 'or' doesn't deserve an answer from the MMA media site of the year.... the part after 'or' is I'm a local karate champion because of the traditional karate training which values kata, kihon & kumite karate methods over sport fighter-pitty pads....
KarateStylist
EDIT: I CAVED INTO THE PRESSURE FROM YOU & MR. CARTOONS. HERE'S THE LEGITIMACY OF YOUR POINT, AND A TKD SEMINAR BUILT JUST FOR YOU.......
Last edited by KarateStylist; 02-14-2013 at 05:18 PM.
1. what the f*ck is a local karate champion , anyways
2. ive heard of state champion , national champion , provincial champion , world champion ,
3. does a local champion compete against guys from the neighborhood? if so , broaden your horizons and fight people who live outside your block , you might find some better competition than guys from the hood ,,
4. im just pulling your chain " karate man "
1. local.
2. local means < regional.... ha ha.... now pulling your chainy....
3. I've been pretty much all over my metropolitan area.... so hood(S) plural is appropriate.....
BTW, there's local guys who can beat me, if you bother to read my prior posting in midst of the 'comic book' insults.... There's really expert people out there I can't touch in fighting & have said so..... don't be so 'gay' {borrowing a quote from Hit Girl in the movie Kick ASS.}....
Quote:
Originally Posted by Discipulus
Hah, that's pretty good.
...for a female...
gO FOR IT big d...................
^^^ In response to MR. VALUE ADDED....
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jukai
Mental discipline, dude.
^^^ More from MR. CARTOONS--- to be 'way cool' it's doooooooooooooode....
KarateStylist
Last edited by KarateStylist; 02-14-2013 at 05:23 PM.
what the fuck is a local karate champion , anyways
ive heard of state champion , national champion , provincial champion , world champion ,
does a local champion compete against guys from the neighborhood? if so , broaden your horizons and fight people who live outside your block , you might find some better competition than guys from the hood ,,
im just pulling your chain " karate man "
Isn't weird how KarateStylists story constantly changes from "I don't spar" to "I compete in TSD tournaments only" to "I'm a local Karate champion!"
I mean, this is the same guy who beats up "local" instructors and whooped a golden glove boxer with one punch, he probably has killed so many people that he just forgets.
__________________
Most people canīt think, most of the remainder won't think, the small fraction who do think mostly can't do it very well.
-R.A.Heinlein
1. Isn't weird how KarateStylists story constantly changes from "I don't spar" to "I compete in TSD tournaments only" to "I'm a local Karate champion!"
2. I mean, this is the same guy who beats up "local" instructors and whooped a golden glove boxer with one punch, he probably has killed so many people that he just forgets.
1. Isn't it 'whatever' that you keep parroting this stuff over & over.... they should rename {FOR YOU} that machida thread {new} on doing the same LIMITED thing over & over....
2. yEAH, and some of them had trained for decade, and shot their mouth off like you.... IOW... they had ALL YOUR QUALIFICATIONS.....
No cartoons, now there's a +....
KarateStylist
P.S. Take Big D over to the Kovacs' pitty pad seminar, will ya.... learn real TKD.... he wants to LEARN KARATE....
1. Isn't it 'whatever' that you keep parroting this stuff over & over.... they should rename {FOR YOU} that machida thread {new} on doing the same LIMITED thing over & over....
2. yEAH, and some of them had trained for decade, and shot their mouth off like you.... IOW... they had ALL YOUR QUALIFICATIONS.....
No cartoons, now there's a +....
KarateStylist
P.S. Take Big D over to the Kovacs' pitty pad seminar, will ya.... learn real TKD.... he wants to LEARN KARATE....
Yeah but every time someone challenges me when I run my mouth off, I dim mak them. You probably don't have the mental discipline to dim mak people.
yes indeed , it is not the same pattern but i can see the heavy influence of shotokan karate in some tkd patterns (except for absence of kicks ), thanks for sharing
yes indeed , it is not the same pattern but i can see the heavy influence of shotokan karate in some tkd patterns (except for absence of kicks ), thanks for sharing
^^^ My, the heavies have been busy little beavers....
^^^ Since you did the work, RE VID#1, I do not like the narrow front stance in this Shotokan karate {apparently} portrayal.... he also uses the C-stepping ***, while TSD proper does a lift & step.
>>> What do you suppose is the point of all this...? BTW, imo NICE DEMO--he's going slow re a learning mode.... he'll get killed in 'real' fighting, HUH?.....
EDIT: VID #2: Not real impressed with the TKD form. He's leaning his torso & hyper=extending the striking hand shoulder too much. Doing poomse, kata right is really tough....
TO BREIFLY SPEAK ON TOPIC: Found 'nother TKD sparring vid showing why, re the standard Japanese kata, Korean poomse, hyung---- WHY KIHON Round kicks were probably disfavored over front kicks for a self defense-fighting strategy.... but what's a dufus like me know....??
KarateStylist
*** C-stepping is legitimate technique, especially suited for actual combat. The greater lift & step of TSD aims @ better mental ^ physical skills....
Last edited by KarateStylist; 02-14-2013 at 07:21 PM.
Reason: Ignore footnote.... focus mitts is where it's at, YEAH....
Ks: Why listen....
Get serious & have me to dinner along with Sinister..... 
KS: cONSOLE... PARROTS
KS: Oh Great One....
